Who would you rank higher on the ATG list Marciano or Phony Boy and why ?

[DiegoFuego]

Floyd.

Marciano beat old as men and shot fighters. Im sorry.

nothing more to add.

oh, except this. some of those old men STILL almost beat Marciano

[1 on 1]

just like pacquiao? pacquiaos career:

cotto - shot and damaged by plaster of paris, lost to clottey already
hatton - ruined by mayweather mentally (words, undefeated record) and physically (beating he took)
oscar - fight night weight: 147 lbs..literally a zombie, last time oscar made this weight was in 2001

morales 1 - past his prime still managed to beat pacquiao
morales 2 - way past his prime
morales 3 - shot to pieces

marquez 1 - marquez beat him in a very close fight
marquez 2 - marquez past his prime but not shot, yet clearly beat him, even ronnie the pacquiao nuthugger thought marquez won that fight

Barrera 1 - best win of pacquiao career, barrera was prime and game.

Singurat - pacquiao got knocked out by a contender
Torrecampo - pacquiao got knocked out by a bum

even though i feel marquez won the fight, pacquiao was competitive with him and i give him credit for that. i also give him credit for beating a great prime version of barrera that was a very good win.

This ain't a PAC thread, lmao

[ChampBox@PR]

Floyd.

Marciano beat old as men and shot fighters. Im sorry.

Indeed. Floyd>>>>>>>>>>>>Marciano no doubt!

[Kagami Taiga]

Dude, if you're gonna look at it that way, then a great HW in your book can never be greater than any other fighter that's able to move up because it's obviously impossible to move up another weightclass for a HW.

no ali is an atg because he fought the best fighters in the world. it just so happend that the best fighters in the world were at hw at the time. who did marciano fight??? archie moore past his prime, jersey joe walcott past his prime and joe louis past his prime. all hofers but all past their prime.

[Joeyzagz]

This is tough for me to decide. I have them tied at the moment.

Floyds best argument is that he did it while moving up through weight classes.


Rocky did it while Ko'ing guys.


If Floyd beats Pac he'll leap frog Marciano as well as a lot of other ATG fighters.

[1 on 1]

no ali is an atg because he fought the best fighters in the world. it just so happend that the best fighters in the world were at hw at the time. who did marciano fight??? archie moore past his prime, jersey joe walcott past his prime and joe louis past his prime. all hofers but all past their prime.

Like I said, "the pot calling the kettle black", hehe