Who recieved the more career threatening fight damage, Tony or Paul?

[BMWM3P]

Margarito.

This is an exaggeration, but it's like the difference between getting shot to death, or being stoned to death.

If a fighter's chin (or brain) deteriorates, it's usually due to accumulation, not just a one-punch KO.

Perfect analogy and it's not the first time. Even when Cheato wins he takes huge beatings like he did against Cotto and to some point Cintron, Mosley owned him and Pac brutalized him. When he gets older Cheato chin will actually be his worst asset.

[Russian Crushin]

Dude that shot does not only affect the physical but the mental. See Ricky Hatton fighting lately???

Williams is fine

1 punch is not as bad as hundreds

Only thing that could affect williams in the future is the mental aspect of it which can be overcome, Physical damage cannot

[Verstyle]

margarito BY FAR

people evolved to get clocked 1 time very hard, get back up

margarito will be feeling the effects the rest of his life

whether its the resto fight, the benn fight, the mancini fight, however different they all were in circumstances, death or serious injury generally doesnt come from one punch

mentally you can't tell, personally i'd rather be knocked out and attribute it to defensive flaws

how does someone rationalize being totally dominated and knowing they've hit their apex and its all downhill

Well put...

[FloydTBE]

magarito no doubt