Who Do You Rank In Terms Of ATG-Archie Moore Or Mickey Walker????

[winky44]

Well? Who do you rank higher in a ATG List????

[Joey Giardello]

Archie moore for me

[winky44]

any1 else???

[mickey malone]

Well? Who do you rank higher in a ATG List????

Moore.... Hands down... More KO's than anybody..

Done better at HW to...

Was also more dominant at L/H than Walker was at MW..

[GJC]

Moore for me, Walker was some fighter though

[winky44]

Moore for me, Walker was some fighter though

Reasons????

[McGoorty]

Reasons????

I put Walker just ahead in the greatness stakes..... but having said that,,,, I think Moore was more talented,,,, and if both were the same size and weight, I'd back Archie in the fight.... I pick Walker because he was more successful across more weights......... but Moore was a helluva MW too........ this is a really tough pick.

[Barn]

Walker ranks higher. He was a better all around fighter than Moore.

Better all round skin colour too.

I will take Walker in this one, but it really is close. Similar resumes , both have a lot of wins against top opposition and even better HOF opposition. They also both lost to the best fighters they ever faced (Greb, Charles). Made defences of their titles, although Walker was a 2 weight champ which really adds to his side, and also gave up lots and lots of weight as much as 50Ibs (Wright.)

As I said I'll take Walker but, only by a razor.

[McGoorty]

Better all round skin colour too.

I will take Walker in this one, but it really is close. Similar resumes , both have a lot of wins against top opposition and even better HOF opposition. They also both lost to the best fighters they ever faced (Greb, Charles). Made defences of their titles, although Walker was a 2 weight champ which really adds to his side, and also gave up lots and lots of weight as much as 50Ibs (Wright.)

As I said I'll take Walker but, only by a shade.

Shade....... DAVE SHADE ?????

[Barn]

Shade....... DAVE SHADE ?????

Well played!