Who's LMW title win was better?

[G Doggy Dog]

Pacquiao beating Margarito for a vacant title at a catchweight and both were unranked at 154?


or


Floyd beating Oscar who won the belt before? no catchweights and Oscar was #1 at 154...FULL WEIGHT...no catchweights at all



WHO R U PICKING?

[The_Demon]

You are clearly trying too prove something to yourself here

Manny has a better resume than floyd,however many threads you start that wont change,get over it

[ИATAS]

[Pullcounter]

Pacquiao beating Margarito for a vacant title at a catchweight and both were unranked at 154?


or


Floyd beating Oscar who won the belt before? no catchweights and Oscar was #1 at 154...FULL WEIGHT...no catchweights at all



WHO R U PICKING?

hey *******. how many more pac threads you gonna make this week?

[G Doggy Dog]

You are clearly trying too prove something to yourself here

Manny has a better resume than floyd,however many threads you start that wont change,get over it

Manny has a great resume up to 140...147 is filled with question marks and catch weights. Drain DLH? When he hasnt fought welterweight since 2001. Drain Cotto? Cuz he has power. No need to drain Clottey, he wont throw a punch the whole fight. Drain Margarito? That fight was a joke itself

[G Doggy Dog]

says the guy with men in his avy and sig. and talks on an internet forum about men who box eachother

[infamous larryx]

obviously floyd...manny-margo was a circus act-catchweight+vacant belt+tony coming off of a year suspenson

floyd beat oscar at 154(no catchweight no vacant belt) for a legit wbc 154 belt

[infamous larryx]

Manny has a great resume up to 140...147 is filled with question marks and catch weights. Drain DLH? When he hasnt fought welterweight since 2001. Drain Cotto? Cuz he has power. No need to drain Clottey, he wont throw a punch the whole fight. Drain Margarito? That fight was a joke itself

naw oscar did that to himself

[cixthree]

You are clearly trying too prove something to yourself here

Manny has a better resume than floyd,however many threads you start that wont change,get over it

Manny has a better res than Floyd? Are you just browsing the names, or are you looking at the conditions of the time when he fought those names?

Manny has more big names (Rematches and Trillogies counted sep) on his resume, but as far as quality, circumstances, weights, closer to or prime at the time, comming off winning streaks and facing The Man in the div... Floyd got that by far..

mannys resume is kinda like Joe Blow CalSlappys if you ask me. joe caught fighters on the slide, he would have NEVER faced prime Roy

[Scott9945]

naw oscar did that to himself

Of course. It was Oscar's idea to return to 147, way before the Pac fight was made. Pacquiao was the one taking the big risk jumping a weight class to fight him. Who here is really stupid enough to believe that anyone ever dictated terms to the #1 attraction in the game?