Willie Pep v Sandy Saddler Best wins comparison

[Humean]

Comparison of the top 20 wins between them in order. Any posters with strong knowledge of Pep, Saddler and other fighters listed here to see how [in]accurate my ranking is?


Pep
Saddler


Best 20 wins
Willie Pep 1948
Willie Pep 1950
Sandy Saddler 1949
Willie Pep 1951
Chalky Wright 1942
Chalky Wright 1944
Chalky Wright1944
Ray Famechon 1950
Ray Famechon 1955
Manuel Ortiz 1944
Paddy DeMarco 1949
Chalky Wright 1946
Sal Bartolo 1943
Sal Bartolo 1946
Phil Terranova 1945
Sal Bartolo 1943
Paddy DeMarco 1948
Miguel Acevedo 1947
Miguel Acevedo 1950
Flash Elorde 1956

[Ray Corso]

I can think of Paddy DeMarco around 46 or 47 also Sal Bartolo around the same time. These were very good wins for Willie!
One thing about Pep is he'd come to fight an areas best guy and carry him to a distance win but if the guy tried taking him out Pep would mess him up.
You could try your best at boxing him but if you started to load up the "fight" would turn quickly. Pep was not void of power he would rather box and not get hit but he stopped some pretty formidable men and if he lost his cool for a moment he'd slug it out! Ray.

[Humean]

I can think of Paddy DeMarco around 46 or 47 also Sal Bartolo around the same time. These were very good wins for Willie!
One thing about Pep is he'd come to fight an areas best guy and carry him to a distance win but if the guy tried taking him out Pep would mess him up.
You could try your best at boxing him but if you started to load up the "fight" would turn quickly. Pep was not void of power he would rather box and not get hit but he stopped some pretty formidable men and if he lost his cool for a moment he'd slug it out! Ray.

I got all the Pep-Bartolo fights on the list but good call on Paddy DeMarco, Pep beat him once and Saddler fought him three times. I'll look into revising the list another day in light of that.