Who did the best job beating Marcos Maidana? Mayweather, Khan, or Alexander?

[nauti4life85]

OP forgot to put Morales on the list.

A shot grandpa version with one eye shut for 11 rounds.

OP also forgot to put that this version of Maidana gives shot Morales his retirement papers, Alexander his 2nd defeat i believe at that time, and Khan an early Garcia KO. You guys seriously sit up here with a straight face and act like Floyd fought the same Maidana from years ago. I don't even like floyd but the hate is strong in here.

[Showtime..]

Devon, Khan, Floyd 2, Morales, Floyd 1.

Different ends of the spectrum:
Devon took him to school.
Floyd got wacked around.

[Dean_Razorback]

OP also forgot to put that this version of Maidana gives shot Morales his retirement papers, Alexander his 2nd defeat i believe at that time, and Khan an early Garcia KO. You guys seriously sit up here with a straight face and act like Floyd fought the same Maidana from years ago. I don't even like floyd but the hate is strong in here.

this

[Bushidō]

Alexander but Mayweather probably fought the best version of Maidana

[Scott9945]

The Khan and Mayweather fights probably enhanced Maidana's reputation more than hurt it. After seeing Alexander beat him I completely wrote off MM as a welterweight contender.

[Divine Hammer]

Alexander, Floyd II, Floyd I then Khan

it's more like:

1. alexander
2. khan
3. floyd 2 or morales
4. floyd 1

both alexander and khan fought everlast mx maidana prime. khan fought and beat a more prime maidana also.

[arraamis]

Alexander but Mayweather probably fought the best version of Maidana

Co-sign!!! Without a doubt ....

Maidana today, would bulldoze Khan and possibly beat Alexander. Out of the three listed (Maidana, Khan, Alexander), Maidana is showing the greatest improvements in skill and technique.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Notice how he says Floyd 1 and 2? Khan didn't need 2 attempts, pillow gloves and dropped him in the process.

Alexander is no doubt #1.

Neither did Mayweather if we're being realistic.

[YOU WILL LOSE]

OP forgot to put Morales on the list.

A shot grandpa version with one eye shut for 11 rounds.

grandpa versiong who fought with no excuses, no holding, no stalling, looking to the ref, running. was never bambi legged.
in the fight right after khan, maidana fought on PPV - his career rose! khan went on to fight mccloskey back in the uk
after maidana, devon went out and out an ancient randall bailey and stunk out the joint yet again, proving the guys only hope is to run out the clock.l maidana lost nothing, his career still rose!

floyd, alexander, khan all looked like clowns and had to make excuses for their "victories" " i ran, i held, i turned my back..but win is a win!"

devon v khan will have holding on the scale of an akinwande vs akinwande bout.

[luisivich]

OP also forgot to put that this version of Maidana gives shot Morales his retirement papers, Alexander his 2nd defeat i believe at that time, and Khan an early Garcia KO. You guys seriously sit up here with a straight face and act like Floyd fought the same Maidana from years ago. I don't even like floyd but the hate is strong in here.

current maidana will beat up thurman, brooke, khan and alexander. if maidana loses in his next fight he is shot fighter because of the beating he recieves from floyd. maidana is not prime before the floyd fights and hopefully not shot after that.