Why do people compare Manny and Floyd to ATG welters when they are naturally smaller?

[Bushbaby]

Listen, just a day ago there was a tread up claiming Floyd is the greatest fighter of all time. When a Floyd fans makes such a ridiculous claim, then believe comparisons will be made.

People are gonna whip out the SRL's, SRR's, Hearns's & Duran's to make a point. That's not their fault. Then there are the Pacman fans that try to compare Pacman to Jesus. What the hell are sensible posters supposed to do other than pull the real atg greats card??

[therealpugilist]

Listen, just a day ago there was a tread up claiming Floyd is the greatest fighter of all time. When a Floyd fans makes such a ridiculous claim, then believe comparisons will be made.

People are gonna whip out the SRL's, SRR's, Hearns's & Duran's to make a point. That's not their fault. Then there are the Pacman fans that try to compare Pacman to Jesus. What the hell are sensible posters supposed to do other than pull the real atg greats card??

put em in with all time greats their size....more all-time greats are at 140 than lower and higher

[The Tase]

i dont know what you are talking about...

Im still waiting on floyd to fight a legit hall of famer in their prime.

He has yet to do it.

[Tamis!]

indeed...here are some fantasy fights I like


Mayweather vs.......Ike Williams, Beau Jack, Julio Cesar Chavez, Tony Canzoneri, Barney Ross, Alexis Arguello, Hector Camacho at 130-135

Manny Pacquaio vs....Willie Pep, Azumah Nelson, Kid Chocolate, Sandy Saddler, Flash Elorde, Salvador Sanchez....126-130

real pick em fights no size disadvantages or prime disadvantages

My ultimate fantasy fight would be;

Floyd or Manny -vs- Pancho Villa.

And I'm confident my boy Pancho smokes both their azzes.

[therealpugilist]

i dont know what you are talking about...

Im still waiting on floyd to fight a legit hall of famer in their prime.

He has yet to do it.

neither guy has...they arent the only great fighters that havent....Pryor didnt, Aguello didnt, Jofre didnt, Holyfield didnt, Lennox Lewis didnt, ODLH didnt...the list goes on...whats your point

[Bushbaby]

neither guy has...they arent the only great fighters that havent....Pryor didnt, Aguello didnt, Jofre didnt, Holyfield didnt, Lennox Lewis didnt, ODLH didnt...the list goes on...whats your point

Soooo, you're saying Oscar didn't fight Tito, B-Hop & Mosley in their primes??

[The Tase]

neither guy has...they arent the only great fighters that havent....Pryor didnt, Aguello didnt, Jofre didnt, Holyfield didnt, Lennox Lewis didnt, ODLH didnt...the list goes on...whats your point

you just exposed yourself as a no nothing alt.

Pac beat barerra 1 and beat marquez 1 & 2.

both were prime and legit hall of famers.

noob.

[Roman Moreno]

you just exposed yourself as a no nothing alt.

Pac beat barerra 1 and beat marquez 1 & 2.

both were prime and legit hall of famers.

noob.

Marquez 1 was a draw.

[sicko]

because both of them have stupid fans who don't know ***** about boxing or the history of boxing and they like the run around and call them "THE GREATEST" then they hype up the fighters on their resumes to try and justify their BULL***** CLAIMS

[-PBP-]

neither guy has...they arent the only great fighters that havent....Pryor didnt, Aguello didnt, Jofre didnt, Holyfield didnt, Lennox Lewis didnt, ODLH didnt...the list goes on...whats your point

None of those guys have been mentioned as the GOAT.