Who has the best resume at welterweight out of these 3?

[Motorcity Cobra]

Spence, Crawford, or Porter?

[Rip Chudd]

1. Porter
2. Spence
3. Crawford

[KTFOKING]

1. Porter
2. Spence
3. Crawford

If it is in terms of wins, Spence beats out Porter. He has the best win of the bunch in Brook, beat Peterson, Algieri and shut out Mikey Garcia....Who I think is at least even with DSG when they face off later this year.

I guess the Ugas win helps Porter out, but that was far from impressive showing.

[Motorcity Cobra]

If it is in terms of wins, Spence beats out Porter. He has the best win of the bunch in Brook, beat Peterson, Algieri and shut out Mikey Garcia....Who I think is at least even with DSG when they face off later this year.

I guess the Ugas win helps Porter out, but that was far from impressive showing.

I don't count that Garcia fight as a legit WW fight. The others are good names but Porter's win over a prime Alexander is more impressive than Spence over Peterson and Algieri

[KTFOKING]

I don't count that Garcia fight as a legit WW fight. The others are good names but Porter's win over a prime Alexander is more impressive than Spence over Peterson and Algieri

Agreed on the Alexander win, disagree on Garcia. I think he will compete with damn near anyone else but Spence and Crawford. But whatever, not going to win that case until he gets in the ring with DSG and then we will get to see just how good he is at WW.

[ShaneMosleySr]

Spence beat Kell Brook who convincingly beat Porter. So Spence is number one.

Porter is second.

Crawford doesn’t even really have a resume at welterweight yet lol.

[Motorcity Cobra]

Agreed on the Alexander win, disagree on Garcia. I think he will compete with damn near anyone else but Spence and Crawford. But whatever, not going to win that case until he gets in the ring with DSG and then we will get to see just how good he is at WW.

If he shows can compete at WW I'll change my opinion. But as of now I don't count that as a legit WW fight. That's why I wanted to see Mikey fight a WW fight before Spence

[The Problem]

Lmao. Dude brook was damaged goods by the time spence fought him. He was more concerned with protecting his eye than actually trying to win the fight. Porter by far.

[Rip Chudd]

If it is in terms of wins, Spence beats out Porter. He has the best win of the bunch in Brook, beat Peterson, Algieri and shut out Mikey Garcia....Who I think is at least even with DSG when they face off later this year.

I guess the Ugas win helps Porter out, but that was far from impressive showing.

I disagree. Spence has one "elite" kind of win in Brook. Algieri is on par with Porter's malignaggi win. Porter also has Alexander, Ugas(although I thought he lost), Garcia who actually had already fought at welterweight unlike Mikey.

So notable bouts for both are as follows:

Spence - Algieri, Brook, Mikey Garcia, Peterson
Porter - Malignaggi, Alexander, Broner, Berto, Thurman(close fight), Garcia, Ugas

I won't even bring up Crawford in this debate. It's between Spence and Porter

[The Problem]

I disagree. Spence has one "elite" kind of win in Brook. Algieri is on par with Porter's malignaggi win. Porter also has Alexander, Ugas(although I thought he lost), Garcia who actually had already fought at welterweight unlike Mikey.

So notable bouts for both are as follows:

Spence - Algieri, Brook, Mikey Garcia, Peterson
Porter - Malignaggi, Alexander, Broner, Berto, Thurman(close fight), Garcia, Ugas

I won't even bring up Crawford in this debate. It's between Spence and Porter

Kell brook is elite now? Who did he beat other than Porter, and only reason he beat porter is because he so much bigger than porter