FMJ considers Cotto an undefeated fighter..what do YOU think?

[texasboi15]

Cotto's losses and perhaps a few wins have come amidst slight controversy. With this in mind, where would you rate Cotto and in terms of wins and losses, what should his record really be?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

His record should really be 36-3 since he also lost to Clottey.

[Jack Napier]

Cotto is controversy free
people here like to complain about stupid shit
Mosley fight was close, either guy coulda won
Cotto got it and nobody can complain
no proof Tony did anything illegal in the 1st fight, Cotto just lost
Clottey fight was even, but Clottey suffered a KD
that was the difference in a Cotto victory
1 or 2 lbs wasn't gonna change the outcome of Cotto losing to Pac
Cotto's record is accurate
he's a good fighter, but he's not great

[~AK49~]

As a cotto fan, stan one could say, i consider him to have one legitimate loss (pacquiao).

I think he went in poorly prepared, horrible gameplan thus playing into pacs strengths, but a loss is a loss.

[~AK49~]

His record should really be 36-3 since he also lost to Clottey.

Cant really complain, clottey gave the fight away.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Cant really complain, clottey gave the fight away.

Yeah he did give the judges the opportunity to shaft him

[DLT]

No. I do think Margarito cheated. It wouldnt be a shock to me if Pac also did a lil something and the weight was an issue but as of now that is a legitmate Loss. Nothing can be proven against Pac and I wouldnt be shocked if he was as clean as a whistle. T

he weight wasnt an issue for me as I think Cotto won a few fights at 140 strictly on the size advantage alone. Also, if Floyd loses this fight or wouldve lost to JMM or Oscar, would that not count because it wasnt at his normal weights? Does Floyd's win over JMM not count?

[Pin Galarga]

I agree with Floyd because like him I don't count a loss by plasters and the other by steroids. Man to Man, He's undefeated.

[Fetta]

Do i think Margarito cheated...Yes. Do i thinjk Pac cheated...Yes. Is it proven...No. So they are officially losses

[The Gambler1981]

Nah he lost both fights, he fought poor fights against both guys and it ended up costing him, I also don't think he was properly prepared in either case.


I think he is exactly the same guy though, nothing really that different about him~