What boxers have reached the hall of fame with no wins over other hall of famers??

[Larry the boss]

Ricardo Lopez maybe?

interesting....let me check..added!!!!!!!!

[HeadBodyBodyBody]

John C. Heenan

[Tony Trick-Pony]

interesting....let me check..added!!!!!!!!

This list could be long. I don't think Orlando Canizales beat any either. He got in because of number of defenses.

i'm pretty sure Brian Mitchell didn't either. Tony Lopez was his biggest name and he's not on there.

[daggum]

interesting....let me check..added!!!!!!!!

you are going to have a lot of names on that list...also the pure stats don't really tell you much. for example kostya tszyu beat an over the hill chavez so hes not on the list. norris beat an over the hill leonard etc...unfortunately to accurately rank fighters you are going to have to use a bit of brain power to determine which fighters were actually good and which were just shells with a name. some guys who don't have a hall of famer are probably better than some who do. i know its crazy!

[BoxingIsGreat]

I always thought Hall of Fame was based mainly on how famous a fighter is and not on their resume. Therefore, people like Gatti and Hamed, would naturally be in.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

I think you can count Johnny Tapia in too.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

you are going to have a lot of names on that list...also the pure stats don't really tell you much. for example kostya tszyu beat an over the hill chavez so hes not on the list. norris beat an over the hill leonard etc...unfortunately to accurately rank fighters you are going to have to use a bit of brain power to determine which fighters were actually good and which were just shells with a name. some guys who don't have a hall of famer are probably better than some who do. i know its crazy!

Brain power?

F that.

I like speed...

[Tony Trick-Pony]

I always thought Hall of Fame was based mainly on how famous a fighter is and not on their resume. Therefore, people like Gatti and Hamed, would naturally be in.

Yeah, this what I always say. The title itself indicates fame and nothing else. Sure. Most guys on the list had great careers and were very talented, but some guys didn't have the greatest talent but gave the fans everything in the ring or were flashy and charismatic, etc. This is why Broner will get in.

[chaosisme]

Orlando Canizales
Pipino Cuevas
Carlos Zarate

[BoxingIsGreat]

Yeah, this what I always say. The title itself indicates fame and nothing else. Sure. Most guys on the list had great careers and were very talented, but some guys didn't have the greatest talent but gave the fans everything in the ring or were flashy and charismatic, etc. This is why Broner will get in.

I agree totally. The title says it all.