Originally posted by chrisJS
View Post
The Titanic may have been the biggest ship 50+ years ago. However, it isn't now. Thus, we don't call it 'the biggest ship in the world' anymore.
Likewise, bouts below 200 pounds may have been called 'heavyweight' bouts 50+ years ago. However, they aren't anymore because heavyweights are much bigger now.
Modern definitions always have greater precedence over ancient definitions. This applies to pretty much everything. From science, to sports.
And hall of fame is an American organisation / establishment. They don't induct boxers based on any objective criteria which evaluates the boxer's quality alone. It's more down to a popularity contest and it mostly inducts local American boxers. That's like me using a Ukrainian hall of fame organisation as a basis to claim that Klitschkos are the greatest heavyweights of all time because it has all the opponents of Klitschkos inducted. It means nothing!
Here is a vital fact:
If we exclude every opponent that Joe Louis fought that weighed below 200 pounds and had 25% or more losses out of his career record in Louis's championship title bouts. Joe Louis beat only 7 opponents in heavyweight world championship title bouts. That is SIGNIFICANTLY less than modern heavyweights.
Most of the opponents that Joe Louis fought in world championship bouts, wouldn't even be allowed to step into the ring against modern heavyweights like a Klitschko or a Lennox Lewis. Wladimir Klitschko never fought opponents with 25% or more losses out of their career records in championship title bouts.
Comment