How would gennedy golovkin do against these guys?

[Half step]

Trinidad gets stopped
Toney carves him up
Mccallum carves him up
Jackson gets stopped
Paz gets stopped
Kessler would be a split decision either way
Froch stops ggg
Chavez jr gets stopped
Winky gets outpointed
Hearns gets stopped
Roy outpoints or stops him
Pavlik gets beaten up
Taylor gets stopped

Yea I said hearns would beat him at first but he was chinny especially at 160 and ggg ain't exactly feather fisted hard to call because Hearn had that game changer kinda power even at 160

[mathed]

A prime 160 Roy destroys him
Toney pot shots him to a wide UD
Froch would be a close fight
McCallum wins a UD
Prime Kessler might win a SD
Prime Taylor might beat him (he was a beast before the Pavlik loss)
Prime Pavlik might beat him (Pavlik's power was no joke, he might be able to hurt GGG)
***EDIT: I didn't even see Martinez on the list, he wins a UD.

[!! Shawn]

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160.
Toney who fought Roy at 160
Mike McCallum at 160
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168
Kessler who beat froch at 168
Froch who ko bute at 168
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?)
Past prime tommy hearns at 160
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1
Roy who was scary at 160
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160

I think Roy,toney,McCallum ,martinez(bad style matchup for ggg),and Hopkins beat him
Maybe Trinidad and winky too
The rest are tough to call

Toney at 160, very close, Id favor GGG since Toney was drained.

McCallum, would be a great fight. That would be a Toss up, maybe favoring McCallum, depending where in his career it was.
Hopkins would have been a good fight

Roy would have taken him apart.

Everyone else gets goodboyed.

[Elroy1]

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160.
Toney who fought Roy at 160 Tough fight for GGG, 50/50
Mike McCallum at 160 GGG KO3
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160 GGG KO early
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168 GGG KO mids
Kessler who beat froch at 168 GGG KO mids
Froch who ko bute at 168 GGG KO late
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160 GGG KO early
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?) GGG KO mids
Past prime tommy hearns at 160 GGG KO late
Jake lamotta at 160 GGG KO1, no exceptions
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160 GGG KO early
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1 GGG UD
Roy who was scary at 160 Tough fight for GGG, think maybe Roy by UD
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160 GGG KO mids
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160 GGG KO early

I think Roy,toney,McCallum ,lamotta,martinez(bad style matchup for ggg),and Hopkins beat him
Maybe Trinidad and froch
The rest are tough to call but they prob lose

Outcomes listed in above quote...

GGG beats all. Tough fights with Toney and Roy in particular.

Only fight would probably favour is a prime Roy.

Of course if Golovkin lands some big bombs, the slack jawed Roy might eat canvas too!

[nivek535]

jones, toney beat ggg by points.
martinez regardless of his age/knees, will lose to a technical fighter who knows how to left hook.

how bout montell griffin?

[Pain~Lucy]

"Welcome to Good Boy Club"

[Elroy1]

jones, toney beat ggg by points.
martinez regardless of his age/knees, will lose to a technical fighter who knows how to left hook.

how bout montell griffin?

Respectable opinion.

Those were very excellent boxers.

Especially Roy.

I think that, in time, Gennady will prove to be the best to date.

[GOD-FR33]

Honestly.......

Honestly. I think GGG has much more to prove against better opposition and he seems to want to prove himself against the best. As for now, unlike a lot of guys who gave predictions, I won't. Time will tell how good he is. He's NEVER faced guys like Toney, Mccallum, Chavez Jr., or Pavlik even, He is a legit middleweight with a good punch BUT we don't know how great his chin is yet. We don't know how well he handles a highly skilled boxer like Ward. Time proves how good a fighter is, not hype. I am too smart to say what he will or won't be at this point. WHY? Because he is unproven. He appears to have some promise though and his fighting style resembles Kostya Tszyu to me. He's accurate and calculating and doesn't waste anything. He also has excellent balance.

[E. O. Wilson]

Golovkin would crap on most of those guys and I'm not even really part of the goodboy brigade

I think the most trouble stylistically would be Toney. Lamotta would be very violent but not really a threat otherwise.

Pavlik liked to walk guys down and Golovkin would instead step in past his hard straights and start ragdolling him. Golovkin is probably above falling for the tricks and potshots that made Jones a lot of his fans during his original run.

Froch is a pretty interesting fight because of his toughness but imagine him throwing semi-blind barrages with his hands down like he did in Groves 1 vs Golovkin who is very tight and disciplined.. He would get caught.

[Motofan]

Short answer is that its way too early to tell. I like God of War as much as the next guy but he hasn't had the chance to show his true level of talent against a top level fighter.