Why ISN'T Jay-Z the greatest of all-time to you guys?

[ßringer]

Lyrically he's pretty damn good, I'll give him that. I just don't like the mother*ucker's voice. It's like nails on a chalkboard to me.

[hhs661]

Never been a huge fan. I respect his hustle but his music isn't something I go back to like I do with others. Not a fan of his style, flow, delivery or sound. He's good but I never put him in convos when talking about my favorites or atgs

[Terrel]

You're just giving more reason on why he should be up there. To cross over and be good at it.

'Course I am, trolling like a mo****er Can't keep with it though.

Jay should definitely be up there. His cross over success is a vital reason as to why. He may not lyrically be a great like many others out there but he has reached more people and become welcomed by everyone (more or less) that you speak too. To deny his greatness (to some degree) is being ignorance and foolishness.

He's a great but top20, lower tier.

[TRAV1$]

His albums sales say nothing about his music, only that he's extremely well-known... same goes for radio-plays etc.

[AssasinKing]

Cos Eminem is better

[borikua]

Last few albums have been wack as hell. the GOAT? hell naw.

[Mohammedini]

Verse....

........................

I rest my case

[Cardinal Buck]

I don't think he's ever made a great album. A bunch of good/very good ones, but nothing great.

[RL_GMA]

I love Jay, but...

[heat27]

I don't think he's ever made a great album. A bunch of good/very good ones, but nothing great.