James Toney vs. Nigel Benn in 1993

[Boxing56]

Who do you think wins? I think Toney is just too skilled and think he even stops Benn.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Toney would have destroyed Benn..

Too much defensive skill, chin, and thunderous counters by Toney would be too much for benn..

Benn was tailor made to get dissected by Toney, much like Barkley

I also felt Eubanks matched up much better vs toneys skillset

[Hatesrats]

Great fight... 160lbs/168lbs Toney was an absolute savage as was Benn.
Defense has to go to James, I defo see this going 12 & Toney getting a win.

[GhostofDempsey]

I would pick Toney over Benn by UD or possible late round stoppage. Better all-around boxer.

[just the facts]

An in shape Toney handles this one but Toney wasn't always in shape.

[FinitoxDinamita]

Toney would have dissected benn and knock him out late.

Toney already got Him and Eubank all rattled at that one talk show. Eubank was on the verge of tears amd Benn was all silent and terrified.

Toney would have destroyed these two guys.

James Toney is greater than hopkins as well.

JAMes toney is what you call a natural fighter, a throwback fighter from the 1940s.

[mlac]

fantastic matchup, toney probobly wins via UD but never count out the Dark destroyer.

Eubank V Toney is a much better fight imo. would of been a slobberknocker

[boliodogs]

James Toney would win in my opinion if he trained hard and was in shape which wasn't always the case with Toney.

[MrClutch85]

Nigel Benn was tailor made for James Toney he would out class him

[Boxing56]

fantastic matchup, toney probobly wins via UD but never count out the Dark destroyer.

Eubank V Toney is a much better fight imo. would of been a slobberknocker

Eubanks had a great chin. Wondering how he would eat Toney's combinations.