Is Floyd Mayweather the greatest to fight primarily out of the shoulder roll style?

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

i'd say james toney got hit to much he sounds like a ******ed punch drunk sipping on some ripple

well watch the film my brother james toney did not get hit a hell of alot... When he moved up he did but hes an atg and his offense out of the shell was deadly!!!!!!!!

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

i'd say james toney got hit to much he sounds like a ******ed punch drunk sipping on some ripple

james toney sparred too much he didnt do much training he just sparred thats all he did

[Francis M.]

The problem is that Floyd is not primarily a shoulder roll fighter.
He does the pull counter which looks like the shoulder roll. Floyd IMO was at his best when he was bouncing in and out like he did with corales and gatti.

[Holywarrior]

james toney's resume > floyd mayweather

by quite a margin

False actually.

Toney has Nunn, McCallum, Barkley, Holyfield, Jirov, Johnson, Williams, Oquendo, Littles


Mayweather has Mosley, Marquez, Cotto, Delahoya, Corrales, Hernandez, Hatton, Castillo, Judah, Canelo, Chavez


Toney was a 3 weight World Champ, Mayweather 5 weight and a simultaneous lineal weight champ in 2 divisions. It's not close, as Mayweather is greater.

[SplitSecond]

False actually.

Toney has Nunn, McCallum, Barkley, Holyfield, Jirov, Johnson, Williams, Oquendo, Littles


Mayweather has Mosley, Marquez, Cotto, Delahoya, Corrales, Hernandez, Hatton, Castillo, Judah, Canelo, Chavez


Toney was a 3 weight World Champ, Mayweather 5 weight and a simultaneous lineal weight champ in 2 divisions. It's not close, as Mayweather is greater.

you realise those guys are prime(besides holyfield) and aren't sht hypejobs like judah(seriously mentioned judah?), and canelo? are you fuking kidding me?

fat and waay undersized marquez, 38 year old mosley, an old hoya but still a good win, a badly drained corrales but sure why not, hatton's good, the other 4 are real good

and i give him credit for claiming up weight, still not past toney though, the names/their resume's, the talent, the timing, is too weak in comparison

[SplitSecond]

damn, the amount of slick african americans toney has faced, really impressed, only just hit me, but has floyd ever fought a mover in his life? let alone a slick brotha?

i suppose there's marquez as someone that can move, but that fight was more of a freak show than anything else with the size/strength disparity that marquez would have been ******ed to try to move against the much taller, faster boxer

floyd really hasn't faced sht but flat footed boxers has he?

[Holywarrior]

you realise those guys are prime(besides holyfield) and aren't sht hypejobs like judah(seriously mentioned judah?), and canelo? are you fuking kidding me?

fat and waay undersized marquez, 38 year old mosley, an old hoya but still a good win, a badly drained corrales but sure why not, hatton's good, the other 4 are real good

and i give him credit for claiming up weight, still not past toney though, the names/their resume's, the talent, the timing, is too weak in comparison

McCallum Prime? You're ok with calling McCallum prime at fcuking cruiserweight but not Judah at welterweight?

Your agenda is showing.

[Holywarrior]

I bet you think Barkley was prime too huh

[SplitSecond]

McCallum Prime? You're ok with calling McCallum prime at fcuking cruiserweight but not Judah at welterweight?

Your agenda is showing.

oh.. so you didn't know they fought three times?...
toney has a win over mccallum at middleweight

never said anything about judah not in prime, judah just sucks

[Holywarrior]

damn, the amount of slick african americans toney has faced, really impressed, only just hit me, but has floyd ever fought a mover in his life? let alone a slick brotha?

i suppose there's marquez as someone that can move, but that fight was more of a freak show than anything else with the size/strength disparity that marquez would have been ******ed to try to move against the much taller, faster boxer

floyd really hasn't faced sht but flat footed boxers has he?

Tiberi is hardly slick and was robbed. Toney got absolutely whitewashed by Jones. Good for Toney