For all you pure boxers, if Ruslan didn't get robbed then Castillo DID get robbed.

[Evol]

just look at the reaction from algerie's corner and his brother when they announced chris as the winner. that should tell it all already. they were as shocked as i was LOL.

[#1Assassin]

lol.. the lengths people go to in order to criticize floyd..

they are two different fights, dude. besides, they didnt even look all that much alike. compubox isnt all that accurate to begin with and there is a lot more that goes into scoring a fight than the amount of punches landing.

algieri and floyd both showed superior ring generalship and defense. they both landed the cleaner punches too. to just say "they both landed more so they both should have won or neither should have won" is beyond ignorant.

[Evol]

lol.. the lengths people go to in order to criticize floyd..

they are two different fights, dude. besides, they didnt even look all that much alike. compubox isnt all that accurate to begin with and there is a lot more that goes into scoring a fight than the amount of punches landing.

algieri and floyd both showed superior ring generalship and defense. they both landed the cleaner punches too. to just say "they both landed more so they both should have won or neither should have won" is beyond ignorant.

nobody is saying its the same fight dumbass.. they're using the same logic that the flomos used. if chris won because he was busier and landed more then shouldnt that means castillo should have won the first time around because he was busier and landed more?

[junior gong]

Its pretty much accepted by anyone thats not a floydspastic that floyd lost that fight. The mere mention of it brings a deluge of floydgimp tears.

[IronDanHamza]

Its pretty much accepted by anyone thats not a floydspastic that floyd lost that fight. The mere mention of it brings a deluge of floydgimp tears.

That's not true the media scores and press scores were split on who won that fight.

[BHopp]

And you can land less punches in other rounds and still win them right?

Isn't that how Floyd "beat" Castillo in fight 1?

Couldn't Provodnikov do the same thing?

Why is it a horrible analogy?

If you need two guys clicking buttons at ringside to determine a fight for you you probably shouldn't be scoring fights anyways.

[Pish Flaps]

IMHO, Floyd is a great boxer but for me he lost the fight with Castillo and Maidana.

Re-watched both fights a couple of times and both times I scored the fights 8 - 4 with Floyd in the losing end.