More exciting fight: Nigel Benn vs James Toney OR Gerald Mccellan vs Jermain Taylor

[SCtrojansbaby]

obviously all fights at 160

Which fight would be more exciting/intriguing

Also who wins each fight and how?

[IronDanHamza]

Toney Vs Benn would be more exciting and more competitive. I see Toney stopping Benn late.

G-man and Taylor wouldn't be competitive IMO exciting while it lasts I guess. G-man takes him out.

[SCtrojansbaby]

I like JT vs Mccellan better because I think it would be cool to see arguable the 2of the top 3 best athletes ever at middleweight.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Toney Vs Benn would be more exciting and more competitive. I see Toney stopping Benn late.

G-man and Taylor wouldn't be competitive IMO exciting while it lasts I guess. G-man takes him out.

What makes you think Mccellan wins so easy?

[The Surgeon]

IMO Both results are a formality: Toney and Mclellan KO wins.


But its a tough call for excitement, i think i'll say Benn vs Toney coz Nige is such an electrifiying fighter