Where do you rank Ezzard Charles on P4P lists?

[Barn]

I have him at 4. Et toi?

[JAB5239]

Easy top ten pick.

[IronDanHamza]

To be honest I think his resume is as good as anyone's.

[StarshipTrooper]

Top-5

[Obama]

He's outside of my top 7. But he could easily be 8. Or he could be 15. I don't think I'd rate him lower than that.

[Boxing Bob]

with 25 career losses?????

[jrosales13]

I think he is a top 10 ATG fighter. Last time I did my list I had him at #5 behind SRR, Greb, Langford, and Armstrong. But, all that can change depending on how I'm feeling that day.

[StarshipTrooper]

with 25 career losses?????

And? Ray Robinson has 19 career losses. Things like that happen when you continue fighting long after you're washed up.

Poet

[Obama]

with 25 career losses?????

Truth be told Charles should have retired even before he gave Rocky Marciano life and death...twice.

13 of those losses were post-Marciano, +2 to Marciano. So only 10 losses before that. At one point Charles had a record of 81-8-1..fighting the best fighters from Middleweight to Heavyweight.

There's like a handful of fighters you can rate in the top 10 in 3 real weight classes. Charles is one of them. And to top it off he rates all the way at #1 in the LHW division.

[BennyST]

with 25 career losses?????

*sigh*

You know a troll when they come up with that comment.