would edwin valero be p4p number 1 if he was still alive?

[Prince Madison]

Im inclined to agree with demarco. What do people think?

[SnoopySmurf]

That's a big question. His suicide meant no fight with Pacquiao, Maidana, Rios etc. What a loss for everyone.

[BrometheusBob.]

via GIPHY

[DoktorSleepless]

Bigdramashow, are you a relatively new boxing fan? Seriously, no judgement. I just get the impression from a number of your threads that you're playing catch up with fighters from the past.

[BrometheusBob.]

Bigdramashow, are you a relatively new boxing fan? Seriously, no judgement. I just get the impression from a number of your threads that you're playing catch up with fighters from the past.

He's just a big Edwin Valero fan. This isn't his first thread suggesting Valero would've been a huge success.

[Robbie Barrett]

Valero was a tomato can crusher, with power, that never fought anyone. Like another fighter you're a fan of.

[*TonyMontana*]

I liked valero too

Who knows

But I will say fighters like that burn out
Look at what happened to pac

[SkillspayBills]

Nope. Keep in mind his next bout was against Pacman. The amount of fighters that I would favor beating Pac from 2008-2010 I would count on one finger.

[*TonyMontana*]

Bigdramashow, are you a relatively new boxing fan? Seriously, no judgement. I just get the impression from a number of your threads that you're playing catch up with fighters from the past.

Boxing was born before any of us
We are all playing catch up

[Prince Madison]

Bigdramashow, are you a relatively new boxing fan? Seriously, no judgement. I just get the impression from a number of your threads that you're playing catch up with fighters from the past.

no offence taken, but ive been a fan of the sport for many years now, just rewatching one of his highlight vids. Was watching valero on the way up back in the day...