P4P lists need to change

[King Caesar]

Boxing Rec's top 25 P4P list:


1 Floyd Mayweather Jr welterweight
2 Manny Pacquiao light middleweight
3 Wladimir Klitschko heavyweight
4 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight
5 Sergio Martinez middleweight
6 Vitali Klitschko heavyweight
7 Juan Manuel Lopez featherweight
8 Juan Manuel Marquez lightweight
9 Lucian Bute super middleweight
10 Timothy Bradley light welterweight
11 Andre Dirrell super middleweight
12 Jean Pascal light heavyweight
13 Fernando Montiel bantamweight
14 David Haye heavyweight
15 Miguel Angel Cotto light middleweight
16 Amir Khan light welterweight
17 Felix Sturm middleweight
18 Chad Dawson light heavyweight
19 Robert Guerrero lightweight
20 Andre Berto welterweight
21 Andre Ward super middleweight
22 Devon Alexander light welterweight
23 Alfredo Angulo light middleweight
24 Mikkel Kessler super middleweight
25 Toshiaki Nishioka super bantamweight

[Toe Injury]

floyd is p4p because of career consistency not because a rough win over old mosley alone somehow amazed the world

margarito literally spent the last couple years unemployed because of loading his gloves and clottey's excuse for doing nothing was "having to poop" (seriously, he said that) but mannys domination and the fact that both were big names gives him #1

truth is that mix is NOT dramatically superior to HW, somebody like juan urango can come within a few wins of eliteness and he's like a poor mans miniature sam peter stylistically

if you want me to take wlad out ill take floyd out too

[ShoulderRoll]

if you want me to take wlad out ill take floyd out too

Floyd's skill set and resume speaks for itself.

If you think that Wlad's jab/right cross/clinch arsenal is in any way comparable, or that he has faced the same quality of opposition, then I don't know what to tell you.

[Steelhammer2011]

Floyd, Manny, and Sergio have earned their PFP status by beating top fighters.


Winning a decision against Shannon Briggs shouldn't put you in the same conversation.

You're always trying to bash and discredit the Klitschkos. Get a life you ******ed troll.

Your sig is stupid.

Lewis went life and death with Briggs. He was badly hurt several times and almost KTFO by Briggs.

Vitali is 40 years old and is well past his prime. He dominated every second of every round and destroyed Briggs. It was a massacre. The fight should have been stopped. Rounds 6,7,8,9,10,12 were all 10-8 rounds. Prime Vitali would've KO'd Briggs.

[ShoulderRoll]

Lennox knocked out a prime Briggs, something that Vitali couldn't do to an old Briggs. End of story.

[Pacquiao'd]

may
pac
martinez

[Toe Injury]

if we're going by career-long domination then wlad and floyd are both p4p

recent "big name" wins, both are inferior to Sergios p williams/k pavlik in the same year

2010: wlad has eddie chambers and sam peter, floyd has just mosely... wow id actually give the edge to wlad again now that you point it out

as for which one you think looks prettier and smoother it's obvious the 240+ pound man will lose but we're talking p4p where you try to ignore size

[Toe Injury]

Lennox knocked out a prime Briggs, something that Vitali couldn't do to an old Briggs. End of story.

and vitali **** all over lewis until a cut stoppage, but what does that have to do with current p4p rankings?

[ShoulderRoll]

if we're going by career-long domination then wlad and floyd are both p4p

Career-wide domination against who, though? The heavyweights are awful.

You just prove my point when you bring up Eddie Chambers and Sam Peter. Pure garbage compared to what Floyd, Manny, and Sergio have had to deal with at the lower weights.

[_original_]

Wow, no wonder this site is filtered with garbage posters.....hardly anybody can create a top ten list due to them only caring about Floyd and Manny


1. Pacquiao
2. Martinez
3. Mayweather Jr.
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Juan Manuel Lopez
6. Fernando Montiel
7. Timothy Bradley
8. Andre Ward
9. Donaire
10. Williams (a KO loss to another p4p fighter does not knock him off my list)