Who's the better vocalist Steven Tyler or Axl Rose?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

They're both ****

nah son the guy in your avi is.

[Burning Phoenix]

Well Tyler is still kicking it... Axl isn't.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

nah son the guy in your avi is.

The word you're looking for is "Special"

[rorymac]

They're both ****

This. Give me Robert Plant or Geddy Lee any day.

[The Noose]

Tyler.

He had the better voice.

GnR are clearly the better band. But thats not the topic u blind ****s.

[REDRUM619]

The better voice belongs to tyler period his tone power and control are vastly superior but as far as whose more acomplished thats diffrent

[Free Uncle Tua]

they both possess a clitoris-like voice

[Tamis!]

Tyler gets my vote if we're talking just vocals.

Tho Axl has the edge with versatility, as he can play some instruments.

[Tamis!]

"Dream On" was Aerosmith's ONE good song. What else did they have that was as great as that song was? "Love in an Elevator"? "Living on the Edge"? That lame song from the "Armageddon" soundtrack?

GNR has a lineup of ****ing epics as long as Slash's hair.

Infact, "Appetite for Destruction" > Aerosmith's entire discography.

Tyler ain't **** but a broke ass Mick Jagger, anyway.

One good song?

You took one song from the epic album "Pump" and you prolly chose it just cause it's the most commercialized?

You didn't listen to the other tracks like "Janie's got a gun, love in an elevator, and the other side"?

You clearly haven't heard all of Aerosmith's songs.

Tho I don't dispute GnR having the more number of hit singles P4P mainly because of a great management team backing them up, while Tyler and Perry's love-hate ride hampered Aerosmith nonstop. Had Tyler and Perry didnt act childishly the band could've done a lot more

[THE REED]

One good song?

You took one song from the epic album "Pump" and you prolly chose it just cause it's the most commercialized?

You didn't listen to the other tracks like "Janie's got a gun, love in an elevator, and the other side"?

You clearly haven't heard all of Aerosmith's songs.

Tho I don't dispute GnR having the more number of hit singles P4P mainly because of a great management team backing them up, while Tyler and Perry's love-hate ride hampered Aerosmith nonstop. Had Tyler and Perry didnt act childishly the band could've done a lot more

True, Axl definitely didnt have any problems with his own band, or one of the best guitarists in the biz.

GnR definitely reached their potential.