Originally posted by Juan Acero
View Post
Louis absolutely improved after the Schmelling fight. Better defence, more varied attacks, more subtelty to his set ups. Louis was basically a kid in the first Schmelling fight, to say he didnt improve after that is laughable. Actually he added to his skillset pretty consistently over his whole career until he retired the first time.
The Galento performance obviously wasnt his best, but an aggressive counter puncher like Louis is liable to get caught occasionally. Look at JMM for example who got dropped many many times. Joe L did KO Galento twice though, in case you have forgotten.
'Bobby' Conn (lol) was an ATG with a great style to move up in weight. Louis definitely underestimated him. He tried to get himself under 200lbs for the fight so it wouldnt be seen as such a mismatch. Conns brilliant movement, incredible lead hand and combination punching gave him fits. Louis KO'd him in the first fight, then easily KO'd him in the second.
The worst points of his career pre retirement you have picked out were KO wins ffs. Tells you all you need to know about Joe's dominance over his division.
Obviously you have the Godoy I fight which many thought he lost (he KO'd Godoy in the rematch), and the JJWalcott I fight which Joe should have lost (he KO'd Walcott in the rematch). But these were aberrations in a stunning career.
He cleared out the era just before him:
Schmelling
Sharkey
Carnera
Baer
Braddock
Uzcudun
JHLewis
Cleared out his own era:
Ramage
Godoy
B.Baer
Galento
Conn
Simon
Ettore
Mann
Farr
Muirrello
Then got a great win over a future great in Jersey Joe Walcott before retiring. His comeback was purely financial. He fought the top guys nonetheless, getting a good win vs Savold in between losing to the likes of Ezzard Charles and Rocky Marciano. He also achieved the vast majority of those wins with brutal KO victories.
Was his era the best ever? Obviously not. You find that happens at HW when one guy dominates. They dont allow any other fighter to shine, and they dont have divisions above and below them to provide other great champions to fight. He still beat the best fighters in the division over a 15 year period.
If you can watch Joe Louis fight and not be conviced he was a brilliant technician and an ATG, then I question your ability to assess a fighter.
Comment