Does Quality trump quantity in a resume?

[Thraxox]

Lets say Fighter A beats:

Terrence Crawford
Keith Thurman
Errol Spence
And in between those three he had fought

Sotto Karass
40 year old Joe Louis Castillo
Samuel Vargas

And then Fighter B Fought and beat
Danny Garcia
Shawn Porter
Amir Khan
Lamont Peterson
Marcos Maidana
Lucas Mathysse
Jessie Vargas

Who do you consider have a better resume?

[Scopedog]

I'd say Fighter B has the better record there. I don't think the guys you listed under fighter B are so much worse than the wins that Fighter A has, though.

[Redd Foxx]

Depends if you're talking about rank or P4P. People always want to "prove" a P4P discussion with a resume but there is no proving something so subjective as P4P because it also accounts for perceived skill. HOW did he look when he won those fights? If P4P was measurable, we wouldn't be arguing about it month after month, year after year.

[SuperSuperLeeds]

Fighter A has three from top ten pound for pound, at the very least he has the three best fighters in his division on his resume( presuming fighter a isnt a middleweight :P) fighter b has zero fighters from top ten pound for pound and none of the top 3 in the division so I would say fighter A has the better resume. obviously both would be amazing records

[Illmatic94]

if all of those wins are considered prime opponents then its fighter B hands down.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Depends if you're talking about rank or P4P. People always want to "prove" a P4P discussion with a resume but there is no proving something so subjective as P4P because it also accounts for perceived skill. HOW did he look when he won those fights? If P4P was measurable, we wouldn't be arguing about it month after month, year after year.

Do people argue about p4p? I hadn't noticed.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Lets say Fighter A beats:

Terrence Crawford
Keith Thurman
Errol Spence
And in between those three he had fought

Sotto Karass
40 year old Joe Louis Castillo
Samuel Vargas

And then Fighter B Fought and beat
Danny Garcia
Shawn Porter
Amir Khan
Lamont Peterson
Marcos Maidana
Lucas Mathysse
Jessie Vargas

Who do you consider have a better resume?

I'm not sure who's better but fighter A and fighter B need to fight each other.

[_Rexy_]

Do people argue about p4p? I hadn't noticed.

when it's a slow week, people argue about ****ing everything