Who's Greater.....Mosely or Cotto?

[Ringlife]

I would have to go with Cotto. He beat Mosley but I like both fighters for always fighting the best.

[-Kev-]

Is this really debatable? Come on Boxingsene.

Leija
Molina
Shannan Taylor
Raul Marquez
Prime De La Hoya in 2000
Prime De La Hoya 2004
Top 5 154 Vargas twice
Collazo
Top 10 154 Ricardo Mayorga
#1 WW Margarito

Mosley*
Quintana
Malignaggi
Not ranked in the top 10 Mayorga
Not ranked in the top 10 and coming off a loss Margarito
Foreman
Clottey
Corley
Judah coming 2 losses and 1 year/half lay off
Bailey
Sosa

Shane Mosley has the greater wins, and even in losing was more respectable.

[-Kev-]

All one needs to mention is Mosley's reign at 135, his win over DLH in 2000, win over Vargas in 2006, and win over Margarito in 2009. Those 3 wins sh-t on Cotto's resume.

[CHOWWOKKA]

I would say Mosley but the whole Balco thing....

[Prince_Pugilist]

Mosley is a steroid cheat.

[bojangles1987]

I want to say Mosley because of Oscar and Margarito. Those two break the tie.

[IronDanHamza]

-A cheater whose greatest win is Mayorga and robbing Oscar

-A Gatekeeper whose greatest win is Mayorga and robbing Mosley

i'm not even going to vote

Mosley clearly won the first fight.

[IronDanHamza]

@ People saying Cotto.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Shane Mosley. Clearly.

[happyman]

oh how quickly people forgive steroid cheats.

that alone makes cotto greater, he isn't a steroid drug cheater