The Best of this Group

[MGG]

From these four who was the best overall fighter, Jimi Bivins, Ezzard Charles, Joey Maxim or Archie Moore ?

(got this idea from the LH thread)

[Johnny_Rocket]

Archie Moore although I belive he did lose to Ezzard Charles a couple times.

[cple]

Ezzard Charles - his overall body of work, ability, and accomplishments stands out among the other three. However, Moore is close.

[JAB5239]

From these four who was the best overall fighter, Jimi Bivins, Ezzard Charles, Joey Maxim or Archie Moore ?

(got this idea from the LH thread)

Charles
Moore
Maxim
Bivins

I wouldn't argue with anyone who wanted to switch Bivins and Maxim.

[KostyaTszyu44]

ezzard easily

archie a close second

dotn know much about the other two im afraid, but archie and ezzard are both ranked top 20 all time p4p

[Kid McCoy]

Charles won 4 out of 5 against Bivins, 3 out of 3 against Moore and 5 out of 5 against Maxim, so it's hard to rate any of them above him. So him first, Archie second, Maxim and Bivins.