Greater Quality of Opposition: PACQUIAO or mayweather?

[Sugar Sting Ray]

Opponents both have in common:

Marquez - Two close fights with Pacquiao fought at JMM's prime weights. One fight with Mayweather at 144 lbs. (Mayweather showed up for the weigh in over the weight limit and outweighed Marquez over 15 lbs. on fight night).

De La Hoya - One split decision loss to Wifebeater (Mayweather ducked the re-match despite the huge money certainty). Lost every round against a cherrypicked lightweight Manny Pacquiao who was chosen because he was small.

Mosley - Past his prime against both. A leftover of Winky Wright, Vernon Forest, and Miguel Cotto. 15 months inactive in fight against Wifebeater. Poor performances before losing every round to friendly Pacquiao.

Hatton - a jr. welterweight who fought above his weight against Floyd and got TKOd on the tenth round of the welterweight fight. Undefeated in his natural weight against Pacquiao and lost his consciousness in the KO of the Decade, 2nd round.

Different opponents:

Mayweather:

Corley, Castillo, Ndou, Jesus Chavez, Baldomir, Judah. All non Hall of Famers. Definitely not 300 pound for pound of all time.

Corrales (non all-time great but possible Hall of Famer), Gatti (leftover of Ward and De La Hoya)

Pacquiao:

KOd # 2 pound for pound ranked lineal featherweight champ Barrera (all time pound for pounder and Hall of famer).

Loss and 2 devastating wins against Morales (all time pound for pounder and Hall of Famer)

Destroyed Cotto (future Hall of Famer, possible top 100 pound for pounder)

Shut out 160 lbs. Joshua Clottey (not Hall of Famer)

Shut out 168 lbs. Margarito (to win 8th alphabet but not lineal title)

[STFU!!]

[sugersean15]

[QUOTE=Sugar Sting Ray;10998549]Opponents both have in common:

Marquez - Two close fights with Pacquiao fought thatJMM's won. One fight with Mayweather at 144 lbs. (Mayweather showed up for the weigh in over the weight limit and outweighed Marquez over 15 lbs. on fight night).

De La Hoya - One split decision loss to Wifebeater (Mayweather ducked the re-match despite the huge money certainty). Lost every round against a cherrypicked lightweight Manny Pacquiao who was chosen because he was small.but pac tricked him by making him a zombie

Mosley - Past his prime against both. A leftover of Winky Wright, Vernon Forest, and Miguel Cotto. 15 months inactive in fight against Wifebeater. Poor performances before losing every round to friendly Pacquiao.but pacquaio was kd

Hatton - a jr. welterweight who fought above his weight against Floyd and got TKOd on the tenth round of the welterweight fight which was his first loss in his unnatural weight against Pacquiao and lost his consciousness in the KO of the week, 2nd round.

Different opponents:

Mayweather:

Corley, Castillo, Ndou, Jesus Chavez, Baldomir, Judah. All Hall of Famers. Definitely 300 pound for pound of all time.

Corrales ( all-time great Hall of Famer), Gatti (wars with Ward and De La Hoya)

Pacquiao:

KOd # 2 pound for pound ranked lineal featherweight champ Barrera (all time pound for pounder and Hall of famer).but was way past his best

Loss and 2 win against a old weight drained Morales (all time pound for pounder and Hall of Famer)

Destroyed Cotto after he had the life beat out of him

Shut out 160 lbs. Joshua Clottey a nobody

Shut out 168 lbs. Margarito to become a paper champion after marg had been found with loaded gloves

i will fix it for ya

[STFU!!]

Lately Floyd easily

Floyds last 5

Ortiz-coming off of best win in career-#2 ww wbc champ

Shane-wba champ-p4p#3-linear ww-coming off of a ko win

Jmm-#2 p4p tune up-coming off of a ko win

Hatton-p4p top 5-former wba ww champion-coming off of a ko win

Oscar-wbc champion-coming off of a ko win


Manny
Jmm-linear lightweight champ-p4p #3-coming off of a ko win

Shane-Coming off of a loss and a draw

Margo-coming off of a ko a year suspension and a tune up

Clottey-coming off of a loss

Cotto-coming off of a win wbo champion

you get my pm.

[ANT_P1989]

Maybe if Pacquiao's last few opponents were coming off wins, not weight drained, and don't have scrambled eggs left for brains.

[miron_lang]

Take out Mosley, Margarito and Clottey from Pac's resume and its still better than Floyd's.

[Explosions]

Pacquiao has the better resume and it's not even close.

[Paclan]

how many of these pointless threads do we really need to have

[The_Demon]

Its clearly Pac,no need for this type of thread

[The Noose]

Can we pleeeeeeeease just vote on c0ck size and be done with it!!!