better resume: tyson (pre douglas) or AJ (pre ruiz)

[Nay_Sayer]

Would you take that Holmes to beat the Wlad that Joshua fought?

In a heartbeat.

[joseph5620]

Would you take that Holmes to beat the Wlad that Joshua fought?

I don't recall Holmes losing to fighters like Ross Puritty.

[Robbie Barrett]

I don't recall Holmes losing to fighters like Ross Puritty.

I don't recall Wlad losing to light heavyweights. I'm not saying Wlad was greater. But the version Joshua fought is better than the Holmes that fought Tyson.

[joseph5620]

I don't recall Wlad losing to light heavyweights. I'm not saying Wlad was greater. But the version Joshua fought is better than the Holmes that fought Tyson.

A HOF light heavyweight far more skilled than Ross Puritty. You have no evidence that the version of Wlad was better.

[Robbie Barrett]

A HOF light heavyweight far more skilled than Ross Puritty.

Any light Heavyweight you want to name wouldn't have beaten Wlad in his first fight at HW.

[qOcOp]

Pre douglas tyson for sure

[joseph5620]

Any light Heavyweight you want to name wouldn't have beaten Wlad in his first fight at HW.

That's your opinion. It's a fact that Spinks was better than Sanders, Brewster, and Puritty.

[Redsox]

wlad had been knocked out in his prime a couple times by decent fighters. he was old and gave joshua hell. the tyson that fought holmes would have creamed Wlad. neither's resume was great.

[Skip Bayless]

Have you seen Holmes' record post the Tyson fight?

Any way you cut it, Tyson's destruction of Holmes was a good win - and probably better than Joshua's win over Wlad considering the following

• Holmes is higher regarded than Wlad
• NOBODY had ever man-handled Holmes in the fashion Tyson did
• Holmes had a good run post Tyson
• Wlad had been KO'ed before
• Joshua Wlad was a competitive fight - Tyson Holmes was NOT

have u seen the holmes that fought tyson? he was so out of it, not even 30% of what he used to be. just because holmes had a good run after doesn't change the fact that holmes was ill prepared and complete **** against tyson.

[Skip Bayless]

Aj has now surpassed Tyson, fact
Tyson never avenge his losses