Rate these guys in terms of boxing ability

[Toney616]

The fighters:
Hagler
Hopkins
Toney
McCallum


Judging criteria:
1: defence
2: offence
3: footwork

[r.burgundy]

toney
hopkins
hagler
mccallum

[Cassius Liston]

Hopkins
Hagler
Toney
Mccallum

[STILL_DETOX]

hopkins
toney
mccallum
hagler

[erikmorales]

Toney
McCallum
Hagler
Hopkins

[prinzemanspopa]

Hopkins
McCallum
Hagler
Toney




Toney was nowhere near as versatile as the others.He always looked good against stationary targets,but any fighter who used lateral movement and gave him angles caused him great,great difficulty.



Too one dimensional to be compared to the others.

[cameronpaul]

Toney was nowhere near as versatile as the others.He always looked good against stationary targets,but any fighter who used lateral movement and gave him angles caused him great,great difficulty.

would any of the other fighters move up and beat hollyfield?

[I am tyler]

Toney
Hopkins
McCallum
Hagler

[prinzemanspopa]

would any of the other fighters move up and beat hollyfield?

If they bulked up accordingly,then yes,they would have dominated the walking corpse that Toney beat.


Holyfield was a shot fighter at the time he fought the fat man.

[DarkTerror88]

Hagler
Hopkins
Toney
McCallum