Is Roy Jones Jr the greatest P4P fighter of all time better than sugar ray leonard ?

[SBleeder]

bhop is better than duran, benitez...nd hearns



Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

LOL, no. I could see ranking Hopkins above Benitez, but Bernard can't even breathe the same air as Duran and Hearns.

[lazy]

I think Leonard and Robinson would beat Jones Jr.

[Gudfella]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gudfella

bhop is better than duran, benitez...nd hearns



Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

LOL, no. I could see ranking Hopkins above Benitez, but Bernard can't even breathe the same air as Duran and Hearns.

nd besides Leonard who did duran beat? nd hearns...o yea...the same guy who lost every he stepped up...duran was scared stiff and not even in his weight class when he was kod by hearns ..which prob was his best win.bhop much bttr overall




Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[marvelousmatt]

He has a good arguement as he moved up to HW and won title.I have him 3rd on all-time P4P LIST.Ray Robinson #1 and now Floyd at #2.RJJ #3. Holyfield #4 and #5 Hearns.

[Gudfella]

rj was near invincible in his prime and his proper weight class...no super middle can edge him.. past ..present.. may b even future..he was more powerful...@160..more of a speed and athlethic fighter...mayb coulda beat Robinson...I neva saw a fight were Robinson was the far slower boxer...interesting match up




Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[huh?]

Robinson's #1 P4P status isn't often questioned, usually just assumed. But... in a fight.... Roy beats both Rays 147-175. Or at any weight in any era. 2Big 2Strong 2Fast 2Much.

[Holywarrior]

Duran
Leonard
Roy
Hagler
Hearns
Benitez

[SBleeder]

Robinson's #1 P4P status isn't often questioned, usually just assumed. But... in a fight.... Roy beats both Rays 147-175. Or at any weight in any era. 2Big 2Strong 2Fast 2Much.

Really. Tell me more about Roy's achievements at 147.

[Richard Wadd]

jones does not have the resume to be the goat and would have lost in his prime to foster, the jinx, and possibly the camden buzzsaw.

and under the old weigh-in rules, he would have not been making 168 at his peak. he'd be a LHW

Jones was top 30 all-time, maybe top 20.

[jackson8]

Jones Jnr was great but so was Leonard and Robinson and comparisons are silly. Most of the time it comes down to who's your favorite more than what you really know. How can you compare them when they fought different fighters. Robinson and Leonard both looked as good as Jones Jnr, just against different fighters and they all fought greats.