Is Calzaghe the best SMW of all time?

[YoungJab]

Without a doubt...

it may have been weak while he was reigning but he was on top for a very long time

He beat who ever there was, you cant complain

Calzaghe is a ATG

[Mersey]

Yes he is. There aren't many great SMW's out there.

[-EAGLE-]

probably yes

[D-MiZe]

Yeah.

[Rich Joke]

Carl Froch will be the best SMW of all time if he beats Kessler

[SN!PER]

Nope, not even in the top 10. Frank Warren and Team Calzaghe cherry picked Joe's opponents and were afraid to match him against proven champions who were in their prime.

Congrats to Joe for beating a long list of bums, tomato cans, and washed-up old men.

Joseph Cowardzaghe, the Fraud from Wales was scared into retirement by Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Williams, and now that Andre Ward exposed Kessler we can be sure he'll never set foot in the ring again.

[Mersey]

Nope, not even in the top 10. Frank Warren and Team Calzaghe cherry picked Joe's opponents and were afraid to match him against proven champions who were in their prime.

Congrats to Joe for beating a long list of bums, tomato cans, and washed-up old men.

Joseph Cowardzaghe, the Coward from Wales was scared into retirement by Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Williams, and now that Andre Ward exposed Kessler we can be sure he'll never set foot in the ring again.

Please tell us who you think the top 10 SMW's are.

[Adamantium]

Nope, not even in the top 10. Frank Warren and Team Calzaghe cherry picked Joe's opponents and were afraid to match him against proven champions who were in their prime.

Congrats to Joe for beating a long list of bums, tomato cans, and washed-up old men.

Joseph Cowardzaghe, the Fraud from Wales was scared into retirement by Dawson, Abraham, Pavlik, and Williams, and now that Andre Ward exposed Kessler we can be sure he'll never set foot in the ring again.

What fighters do you think he ducked at smw?

[GoogleMe]

Are you from another planet? Cherry picking? Who challenged Joe at SMW? Who was the great competetion he didn't fight at SMW?

[Mersey]

Let's see your top 10 SMW's Valero.