who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[-PBP-]

Shane Mosley was most definitely not P4P number 3 when he faced Mayweather.

First off..yes he was

Second, you missing the point of me posting all that stuff. It was to correct what Lary was saying.

Floyd hasn't defeated more champions

He hasn't been in more championship fights

he hasn't won more championship fights

He's beaten one more p4p ranked fighter but lets be serious

Nelson, McGirt, Chavez >>>>>> Corrales, Mosley, Marquez, Castillo


Lastly if you look at all the names I posted and still don't see how Whitakers resume shyts on Floyd's, then its just not worth arguing anymore.

[BennyST]

Not you as well, and to think that I actually used too like you Benny.

Have you ever heard of this guy? Supposedly he was pretty good.

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Fighting_Harada

[DeadLikeMe]

Have you ever heard of this guy? Supposedly he was pretty good.

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Fighting_Harada

I just wish that Inagural Champion guy ended up being half the fighter guys like Jofre, Harada and Kingpetch were...talk about wasted potential.

[TechN9ne84]

I voted for Floyd, but in my personal opinion it's really close. Voted for Floyd because he's still working on his resume, and he's still undefeated. Pernell has a few questionable losses and some really great wins. Floyd no losses and some really great wins. Also i saw somebody talking bad about Emmanuel Augustus. That is the most robbed fighter in history simply because judges don't appreciate his fighting style. He has a style that would give most fighters major problems since it's so unorthodox. Thats why fighters like Roy Jones Jr, and Pernell Whitaker were so good. You can't properly train for such an unorthodox style. You have to learn in the ring.

[sdcluser]

Got pernell.

[MrTambourineMan]

The Mongs of this thread:

Larryxxx
Andyrewww
Brandish
DiegoFuego
Light_Speed

[jas]

this is a really difficult one.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Tough,, I would say pernell because he fought more prime fighters but they are super close and Floyd would most likely be higher on most lists since he was a bigger star

[IronDanHamza]

Can't believe I just read all of that.

Now my head hurts abit.

I went abit hard on you Larry, I apologise. Some of the things you've said here are so far from reality but let's face it, Larry's a Boxingscene PPV draw.

"Mosley's LW Run >>>>> Nelson's career"

What a Zinger!

[SkillspayBills]

Floyd is top 20 ATG and his career is still ongoing. Pernell is up there as well. But I give the edge to Money.