Is Joe Calzaghe an all-time great?

[IMDAZED]

True, but it was still a great win.

Great? No.

[Sick/]

thread has been done about 1000 times before

[Royalty]

Great? No.

Beating the second best fighter in the division, when you're number one, isn't a great win?

Please..

[IMDAZED]

Beating the second best fighter in the division, when you're number one, isn't a great win?

Please..

Depends on who the second best fighter is.

[Shazam!]

So funny the way Jeff Lacy was built up to beat Joe and he got humiliated. No one could beat Joe. He'd still be undefeated now if he was fighting. An incredible achievement and one that automatically qualifies a fighter as an ATG. I think pretty much everyone I've met who's in boxing and who knows about boxing acknowledges this.

[Picazo]

in this era he did do great things but....all time?? im not sure, i wouldnt argue if someone felt like he is an ATG though.

[The_Demon]

imo yes but i can see why people say otherwise

[Greg House]

I think a good limit to judge whether a fighter is an all-time great would be the top 50. It's up to you, though.

It's not a top 50...in my opinion

[PensionKiller]

I'm a fan of him, but HOF possibly, he should be in my eyes but there are some questions.

As for ATG, no.

This is due to waitor liquor making me realise that ATG and HOF is not easy to get into.

[Pirao]

I think yes.