Was this 49-0 unbeaten fighter truly great?

[Lead Cenobite]

I think he was:



Because I think unbeaten streaks automatically make you an all time great.

[The Hammer]

I think he was:



Because I think unbeaten streaks automatically make you an all time great.

No.

Floyd Mayweather and Faruq Saleem are far from great, and they are unbeaten.

[TheGreatA]

Nielsen was really 62-0. The loss to Dicky Ryan shouldn't count.

He had wins over prime Larry Holmes, Tim Witherspoon, Tony Tubbs, Orlin Norris, Mike Hunter, Jeremy Williams, Peter McNeeley, Ross Puritty, Dicky Ryan, Crawford Grimsley...

[WhoreUs]

Nielsen was really 62-0. The loss to Dicky Ryan shouldn't count.

He had wins over prime Larry Holmes, Tim Witherspoon, Tony Tubbs, Orlin Norris, Mike Hunter, Jeremy Williams, Peter McNeeley, Ross Puritty, Dicky Ryan, Crawford Grimsley...

dicky ryan was an all-time great.

[dwidsid3d]

I think he was:



Because I think unbeaten streaks automatically make you an all time great.

So Thomas Damgaard at 49-0 with 37 ko's was a great when Gatti at the end of his carrear ko'd him or the Branco(undefeated)that Gatti fought was an ALL TIME GREAT.

[Deja_Vous]

I think he was:



Because I think unbeaten streaks automatically make you an all time great.

Well he did beat everybody they put in front of him.

That seems to be the only criterea to be an ATG in the minds of far too many around here.

[TheGreatA]

dicky ryan was an all-time great.

Dicky Ryan at his best was a durable, clever counter puncher who could make anybody look bad with his style. I rank him #839 on my HW all-time great list and #9843 on my p4p list.

[Deja_Vous]

No.

Floyd Mayweather and Faruq Saleem are far from great, and they are unbeaten.

Mayweather is closer to great than Sloppy Joe.

[WhoreUs]

Dicky Ryan at his best was a durable, clever counter puncher who could make anybody look bad with his style. I rank him #839 on my HW all-time great list and #9843 on my p4p list.

where does tua rank?



and why did you let people steal your name?

[Chr0nic]

Dicky Ryan at his best was a durable, clever counter puncher who could make anybody look bad with his style. I rank him #839 on my HW all-time great list and #9843 on my p4p list.

do you seriously have an all-time list?

post it