James toney that beat Holyfield vs David haye

[Half step]

Who wins and how?

[Larry the boss]

interesting fight...Holyfield was beyond shot but i would have to go with Toney..to tough and was still hard to hit

[ShoulderRoll]

James Toney wins with a body shot KO in the 9th round.

[beez721]

Who wins and how?

tough to call. holyfield was shot. haye doesn't look nearly as good when he gets guys that can defend and take a shot which toney was great at. haye had the big edge in handspeed and power tho and would maybe pot shot his way to a close decision win imo. no way hes starching toney tho. that guy was one of the toughest sob's ever in the sport

[Elroy1]

David Haye would have easily KO'ed that Toney and have UD'd that Holyfield.

Haye is slicker and faster than either of those 2 and possesses a much harder whack which he'd land with much more flush and more frequently than say, Sam Peter did.

Almost no chance for "Fat Toney" to survive.

[DARKSEID]

David Haye would have easily KO'ed that Toney and have UD'd that Holyfield.

Haye is slicker and faster than either of those 2 and possesses a much harder whack which he'd land with much more flush and more frequently than say, Sam Peter did.

Almost no chance for "Fat Toney" to survive.

[El-blanco]

tough to call. holyfield was shot. haye doesn't look nearly as good when he gets guys that can defend and take a shot which toney was great at. haye had the big edge in handspeed and power tho and would maybe pot shot his way to a close decision win imo. no way hes starching toney tho. that guy was one of the toughest sob's ever in the sport

Great post. Toney, skill wise, is a top fighter. Haye has nothing for him.

[Jewish-Reptile]

David Haye would have easily KO'ed that Toney and have UD'd that Holyfield.

Haye is slicker and faster than either of those 2 and possesses a much harder whack which he'd land with much more flush and more frequently than say, Sam Peter did.

Almost no chance for "Fat Toney" to survive.

Lets not start trying to elevate Haye's status to make Wlad's win appear greater than it was.Haye's legacy at the weight is a sad and pathetic story.

[White_Knight]

Holyfield was shot by that point and had no significant wins thereafter. In fact, that loss was 1 of 3 in a row for Holyfield. I'd have to go with Haye.

[Elroy1]

Lets not start trying to elevate Haye's status to make Wlad's win appear greater than it was.Haye's legacy at the weight is a sad and pathetic story.

Nobody is doing anything of the sort. WK has nothing to do with this topic.

I was just stating facts..

Haye would have belted any version of Toney, and that version of Holyfield, without fail!