Chino Maidana vs Josh Taylor who takes it?

[Bitedown]

No such thing as “current Maidana.” Only 140 which was his prime.

Maidana wasn’t in his prime till he improved his jab..that’s at 147

Maidana at 140 probably beats Taylor ... in a fun to watch brawl

[Tatabanya]

The best Maidana destroys Taylor.

[John Locke]

Taylor for me, he's too good. Having Prograis, Postol and Baranchyk on your resume after 16 fights is seriously impressive.

[John Locke]

The best Maidana destroys Taylor.

Based on what? What top level fighter did Maidana ever destroy? Maidana's best wins are Broner and Victor Ortiz...

[Tatabanya]

Based on what? What top level fighter did Maidana ever destroy? Maidana's best wins are Broner and Victor Ortiz...

I still don't consider Taylor "top level".

[Tatabanya]

Taylor for me, he's too good. Having Prograis, Postol and Baranchyk on your resume after 16 fights is seriously impressive.

Let me clarify my previous post.

Taylor is still at the start of a potential ascension to greatness in spite of the wins you mention, whereas Maidana has shared the ring with lots of harder and more experienced opponents.

As of now I see Maidana's best too much for Taylor's best. In the future I might review my opinion, though Taylor has already shown something in his behavior that doesn't bode well for his future.

[boliodogs]

What weight?????? I pick Taylor. Prime against prime I think Maidana wins but he is a boxing old man now who has been out for yeas and nobody knows how good he is now. Funna Funna Funna