Comments Thread For: Mancini: If Mayweather Beats GGG, Top 10 of All-Time

[WESS]

Oh then I took a dump on your faulty logic. Oops. Here's some toilet paper.

You didn't do anything other than make an irrelevant post, actually...

Keep your head up.

[The plunger man]

Mancini is not in the top 50 of all time....short reign career, bad defence......reckless......and open to facial damage....and lost all his big fights.......floyd is not top 10 because he chooses the easy route...fights only where he knows he will be protected..which is Vegas......has no power......contant hugging......afraid to mix it up...picks easy foes.....gets gift decisions. ( Castillo , maidana 1. Pacquaio ) .....sorry to say but mayweather will not go down in the top 15 in years to come simply because he lacks a Ali or srl desire to beat the best......bottom line

[SlySlickSmooth]

Floyd would get ridiculous praise if he beat GGG at 160, that's all there is to it. He would still get (some) credit if it was a 156 catchweight, why you ask, because GGG signed to fight.

[Easy Work.]

Lol he just beat the dude everyone wanted him to fight and still doesnt get credit from alot of fans. Even if he does beat ggg at any weight, he wont get credit. hes already arguably top 10

[twosweethooks]

lol at Floyd getting credit. First off if he doesnt fight GGG at 160 without a rehydration clause he will get no credit. Second if he fights defensively he will get no credit and haters will say he ran.

Only way he gets credit is to fight at 160lbs against a 172-178lbs GGG on fight night, fight offensively and stops him, anybody who thinks it is physically possible is a fool.

After that fight people will say Floyd needs to fight Ward to crack the top 25 atg.

Look at my sig, haters like Hugh Grant were saying a few years ago that floyd had to fight Cotto DLH Mosley Hatton to be with the legends, now these same haters are still hating, even if he has beaten all these guys + Pacquiao, Alvarez, Marquez and others

But fighting Berto he is an all time great ? Get outa here

[Santa_]

No Mancini, it takes more than 1 fight to crack the top 10 spot.

[SlySlickSmooth]

Lol he just beat the dude everyone wanted him to fight and still doesnt get credit from alot of fans. Even if he does beat ggg at any weight, he wont get credit. hes already arguably top 10

what the hell is the point in being a boxing fan if this is gonna be your stance.

Floyd gets credit whether fake ass fans don't like it or not.

[b00g13man]

What has GGG done that beating him will be some kind of big legendary feat? So Floyd beats a guy who beat Geale and Rubio. Wow.

Exactly.....

[ИATAS]

No Mancini, it takes more than 1 fight to crack the top 10 spot.

Pretty sure Floyd has more than one fight.

Hypothetically speaking here of course, if Floyd did move up to 160, beat Golovkin and retired let's say 50-0, if people rated him top 10 there wouldn't be much of an argument against it. In other words, they wouldn't necessarily be wrong.

[ИATAS]

What has GGG done that beating him will be some kind of big legendary feat? So Floyd beats a guy who beat Geale and Rubio. Wow.

You're right Kev, moving up to middleweight and beating the #1 middleweight in the world means little. Beating Berto, now that would make him top ten!