Mayweather vs Maidana as seen from an unbiased boxing fan.

[Salardo]

No, Mayweather did not dominate that fight. And no, he did not win 9 rounds 3 as I have read here. And no, he did not win 8 rounds to 4 or even 7 rounds to 5.
I scored it for Maidana by 2 points.
I gave Maidana rounds 1,3,4,5,8 and 11. I gave Mayweather rounds 6,7,9 and 12 and I scored rounds 2 and 10 as a Draw.
A few rounds were close. I gave 2 close rounds to Mayweather and I gave 2 close rounds to Maidana. I have a hard time seeing how that fight can be a draw to be honest and it wasn't a 10 rounds to 2 victory for Maidana either.
Maidana won though.

[_original_]

[AltairLOM]

youre a ****** for giving round 11 for Maidana and thinking he won the fight.

[Xi_]

No, Mayweather did not dominate that fight. And no, he did not win 9 rounds 3 as I have read here. And no, he did not win 8 rounds to 4 or even 7 rounds to 5.
I scored it for Maidana by 2 points.
I gave Maidana rounds 1,3,4,5,8 and 11. I gave Mayweather rounds 6,7,9 and 12 and I scored rounds 2 and 10 as a Draw.
A few rounds were close. I gave 2 close rounds to Mayweather and I gave 2 close rounds to Maidana. I have a hard time seeing how that fight can be a draw to be honest and it wasn't a 10 rounds to 2 victory for Maidana either.
Maidana won though.

no way in hell did maidana win 11 or 10.

[Salardo]

youre a ****** for giving round 11 for Maidana and thinking he won the fight.

Round 11 was close and Maidana barely edged it. Round 12 was very close either and I felt Mayweather edged it.

no way in hell did maidana win 11 or 10.

I scored round 10 a draw, as for round 11, see above.

[lfc19titles]

floyd definitely lost that fight

yesterday explained why floyd has avoided the best guys, he is trash

[neoz]

No, Mayweather did not dominate that fight. And no, he did not win 9 rounds 3 as I have read here. And no, he did not win 8 rounds to 4 or even 7 rounds to 5.
I scored it for Maidana by 2 points.
I gave Maidana rounds 1,3,4,5,8 and 11. I gave Mayweather rounds 6,7,9 and 12 and I scored rounds 2 and 10 as a Draw.
A few rounds were close. I gave 2 close rounds to Mayweather and I gave 2 close rounds to Maidana. I have a hard time seeing how that fight can be a draw to be honest and it wasn't a 10 rounds to 2 victory for Maidana either.
Maidana won though.

Good unbiased analysis.
But boxing is corrupt.

[Xi_]

Round 11 was close and Maidana barely edged it. Round 12 was very close either and I felt Mayweather edged it.


I scored round 10 a draw, as for round 11, see above.

maidana didn't land any clean work in 10 or 11......floyd was tagging maidana with combos.

[MindBat]

No, Mayweather did not dominate that fight. And no, he did not win 9 rounds 3 as I have read here. And no, he did not win 8 rounds to 4 or even 7 rounds to 5.
I scored it for Maidana by 2 points.
I gave Maidana rounds 1,3,4,5,8 and 11. I gave Mayweather rounds 6,7,9 and 12 and I scored rounds 2 and 10 as a Draw.
A few rounds were close. I gave 2 close rounds to Mayweather and I gave 2 close rounds to Maidana. I have a hard time seeing how that fight can be a draw to be honest and it wasn't a 10 rounds to 2 victory for Maidana either.
Maidana won though.

Have you rewatched the fight without the beer in your hand?
.

[hugh grant]

Ive only seen first half of the fight, and it was Maidana bullying Floyd around the ring.
To score Floyds punches I would need the benefit of slo mo.