I think floyd mayweather is top 10 of all time

[J The UnBiased]

Top 10 of All Time
10.) Carl Froch
9.) Andre Berto
8.) Winky Wright
7.) Paul Spadafora
6.) Chris John
5.) Mickey Ward
4.) Ray Mancini
3.) Antonio Margarito
2.) Chris Arreola
1.) GGG

[GRboxing]

Top 10 of All Time
10.) Carl Froch
9.) Andre Berto
8.) Winky Wright
7.) Paul Spadafora
6.) Chris John
5.) Mickey Ward
4.) Ray Mancini
3.) Antonio Margarito
2.) Chris Arreola
1.) GGG

Sven Ottke > Golovkin

[Granite]

[J The UnBiased]

Sven Ottke > Golovkin

You may be onto something their

[GRboxing]

You may be onto something their

Golovkin waited to turn pro so long because he was ducking Ottke.

[Verstyle]

no disrespect but floyd aint top 10 ATG

he is top 25-50 but not enough big fights to propel him any higher,,

maybe if he had on his resume:
freitas
casamoyer
spadafora
johnston
tzsyu
hatton at 140
cotto in 2008
shane in 2007
margs 2008-09
manny 2009-2012
canelo no catchweight

if he had some of these fights, not all, on his resume then his ranking would be higher,,

he def needed manny, tszyu, and prime cotto or shane on his resume
I dont think anyone has pernell top 10 ATG,, maybe top 10 of the last 30 years, but not of all time....

floyd is a great fighter, but top 10 ATG is a bit much
Floyd is a great fighter,, just not top 10 ATG

what a **** list..if he didnt fight who he did fight then you'd have them on the damn list,people do to much when it comes to floyd,oh he didnt fight so and son..oh he fought this fighter but a year to late and not at the right weight...wtf?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

1. sven ottke
2. marciano
3. calzaghe
4. samuel peter
5. pavlik
6. ike ibeubuchi
7. floyd
8. sturm
9.chavez jr
10. reggie strickland

[Sugar Adam Ali]

what a **** list..if he didnt fight who he did fight then you'd have them on the damn list,people do to much when it comes to floyd,oh he didnt fight so and son..oh he fought this fighter but a year to late and not at the right weight...wtf?

listen dude, we are talking about ATG

if you think floyd beating ortiz, ghost, shot cotto, old mosely, old oscar, compares to say

SRL beating prime hearns, benetiz, duran, hagler

ali beating liston, frazier, foreman, etc

then more power to you......

Remember we are talking about ATG not the last 10 years.....

[Sam Donald]

i said floyd..top 10 not top 5... hes done more than whitaker

[SD180sx]

Floyds definitely in the top 10 greatest fighter of this era. But I'll wait until his done to see where he ranks amongst the ATG.