Matthysse in the top 10 P4P In My Opinion

[AP♠]

Lucas isn't p4p material yet. Pederson himself wasn't even a p4p entry which is Mattysse's best win up to date. He has to beat Garcia and vice versa for any of them to reach the list.

[PureBoxingCEO]

Right now he is top 20 no doubt, but after he KOs Dannh Garcia he will jump to Top 10 easily.

[Cleto_Reyes]

Right now he is top 20 no doubt, but after he KOs Dannh Garcia he will jump to Top 10 easily.

This^^.........

[Jcsuper]

Right now he is top 20 no doubt, but after he KOs Dannh Garcia he will jump to Top 10 easily.

I agree with this

[Goldie]

yada yada, stop getting butthurt over an opinion

Mayweather hasn't fought the requisite competition lately or even often enough to justify a spot at No.1, he's there on reputation not beating unheralded Guerrero or a past-prime Cotto one fight a year

So who did you want Mayweather to fight instead of Cotto and Guerrero?

[Outwest Exp 355]

Top ten p4p is fair. Hes the best in arguably the best division.

[WarMaidana]

i think so... heres my list in order

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Martinez
Pacquaio
Wladamir Klitschko
Carl Froch
Bradley
Matthysse
Mares

I dont agree with rigondeauz on there, he has what 12 fights? I dont care of his amateur background and ya he beat donaire which was a great win, but one good opponenet doesn't cut it

[Boxing Bob]

i think so... heres my list in order

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Martinez
Pacquaio
Wladamir Klitschko
Carl Froch
Bradley
Matthysse
Mares

I dont agree with rigondeauz on there, he has what 12 fights? I dont care of his amateur background and ya he beat donaire which was a great win, but one good opponenet doesn't cut it

So according to you, when Matthysse brutally KOed a fringe top 20 (Peterson) this gets him top 10 p4p status, but when Rigo completely dominated a top 5 (Donaire) over 12 rds it won't get him the top 10 p4p status? I disagree

[Fetta]

Not yet but he is close. He beats Garcia and he will be.

[Weebler I]

Whats your list look like

I prefer to sit back and criticise other people's lists J/k bro, your list is a lot more credible than most I've seen, I wasn't actually attacking you as most lists have FMJ on top of them.

So who did you want Mayweather to fight instead of Cotto and Guerrero?

Do you have ask? But regardless, do you think 1 a year is enough to stay on top of any list? It's not like it was even prime top opponents.