Is Jorge Arce's career hall of fame worthy?

[RedDevil5]

Cotto isn't even HOF worthy, but he will most likely get in due to popularity.

Exactly every time he stepped up he lost

Margarito
PAC
Mayweather
Trout

[Garofalo]

Check back in the latino lounge to see the reason I made this thread in the first place.

Dont mean to start what I think you think I mean to start. Just proving a point.

Funny how this thread was created by a Puerto Rican who saw his # 1 ranked Puerto Rican hero, Wilfredo Vasquez Jr get spanked by his grandpa Arce.

After that he passed the chancleta over to Papitos' Uncle, Nonito to further continue the whacking.

[-Hyperion-]

whats this interim title bs? the only weightclass were he was JUST an interim titlist was flyweight.

he was a FULL titlist at 108,115, 118 and 122 even if some of them were vacant....and a Cotto fan wouldnt dare criticise someone who wins a bunch of vacant belts and loses against his best opponents would he???



anyway, to the question, teh IBHOF has low standards, so he's just as deserving as some of the people who are already there....

[ELHURACAN58]

Exactly every time he stepped up he lost

Margarito
PAC
Mayweather
Trout

Why are you even putting Trout in that category? The one who stepped up in that fight was Trout, and he was way bigger.

Cotto in reality is 5-3 in Top fights.

First was against Quintana where he stepped up in weight and competition.

Then came Judah who was seen as a tough fight for him considering he gave Mayweather hell for the first half of the fight and was once the unified champ. Cotto never fought a guy like Judah before. Then came Mosley who was already a hall of famer and hadnt lost in some time. The Margarito where he lost. Then Pacquiao where he also lost. Then Foreman as it was going up another division. Then the margarito rematch. Then the Mayweather fight.

[RedDevil5]

This idiot dosent know the diffrence between interim and vacant hahahahahah

[MVOLT]

whats this interim title bs? the only weightclass were he was JUST an interim titlist was flyweight.

he was a FULL titlist at 108,115, 118 and 122 even if some of them were vacant....and a Cotto fan wouldnt dare criticise someone who wins a bunch of vacant belts and loses against his best opponents would he???



anyway, to the question, teh IBHOF has low standards, so he's just as deserving as some of the people who are already there....

arce beat more champs for there belts then cotto did

[GoldSugar]

Yeah definitely. 2 wins over Hussein, the win over WV2, Castillo, Singsurat, alvarez, Makepula, Choi and Cordoba? As well as moving up these divisions to do so he should definitely make it.

More established than godamned Johansson

[-Hyperion-]

arce beat more champs for there belts then cotto did

yep Choi for his jr flyweight and Vazquez for the Jr Bnatamweight, against Cotto's Foreman....i guess you can give Cotto credit for beating Clottey becuase if Clottey hadnt been stripped, that would've been a unification...

[ELHURACAN58]

whats this interim title bs? the only weightclass were he was JUST an interim titlist was flyweight.

he was a FULL titlist at 108,115, 118 and 122 even if some of them were vacant....and a Cotto fan wouldnt dare criticise someone who wins a bunch of vacant belts and loses against his best opponents would he???



anyway, to the question, teh IBHOF has low standards, so he's just as deserving as some of the people who are already there....

Ok how many titlists has Arce beaten in his career wise guy?

Funny how you guys say he is worthy "because the hall of fame has low expectations".

The thread title was "Is he HoF worthy or not?" and not "Does the HoF have enough low expectations to allow Arce into the HoF?". But then Im already getting my answers with these posts.

Funny how mexicans keep bringing puerto ricans into every single thread they can gawd!

[esconore]

Arce and Cotto should both get inducted.