Floyd is top 100 Manny is top 3 Deal with it son ..how is this possible____________

[-EX-]

Pac's resume is better but not by much...

PensionKiller is either joking, drunk, or has lost his mind...

[Carpe Diem]

how is mannys resume better than floyds??

It is better than Floyd's. But when Floyd beat him, i don't see how anyone can say Pac's resume is better. Floyd need a guy of Pac's caliber on his record to sealed his resume/legacy.

[jrosales13]

ok ok..at 135 david diaz is a joke

140-hatton was done floyd been ****ed him up

145??is that even a division??
and clottey-best win was against judah and he was coming off of a loss

morales beat him the first time and manny rematched him after he got shut out my raheem at 135 and made him drain himself to 130 even putting in weight penalties..come on

Chavez-Whitaker

[jrosales13]

lol..you should watch more tv..find me an all time great list that doesnt include floyd.....how can manny be there and floyd not be????mannys only the p4p king cause floyd retired

A boxing historian by the name of Mike Silver. Who is respected in the boxing circle said that Floyd is not even top 100 ATG. And, to be fair he also said Pac is not a top 100 ATG.

I chuckled when I read his comments.

[damned1974]

If you SKIM over their resumes,then on the surface it may look like Pac's career is a bit better-to the casual fan.

When you actually look at where Pac's opponents careers were headed or were at when he fought them,it would seem that Floyd actually has the better resume based on quality,not just exclusively based on marquee names out of their primes or that had question marks before entering their fights with Manny.. .

[jrosales13]

130 floyd is the man. 135 castillo had a grweat 2st fight... gatti is tailor made by milliemetres.. baldo isn just not that good imo oscar semi retired....

mosely was the champ but come on, he was old and that long lay off was just very bad for him.

jmm was comeback but 147 was just too much

hatton, again at 147 he was poor. 140 he had a slightly better chance but brotez was **** anyway

**** baldo, he's better than david diaz but **** him

They're even. I guess you can give the edge to Baldo cuz of the lineage but skill wise they're even.

[pasawayako]

I agree with pensionkiller.......

pensionkiller >>>>>> larryx2010

[Hi-Dro]

I suggest you guys look at Spray's thread to answer the question to this thread

[Ether]

Ban whomever said Manny beats Prime Oscar and Prime Tito.

Jesus christ, report them.

[PensionKiller]

lol@Manny being good with mindgames-aka lies that he caught and proven to be false with....

Him being a ncie guy is a mind game. People don't want to kill him, he smiles at them pre fight. Suckered

revisioninst history........was anyone worried about Shane's age or long layoff when they thought Floyd would never fight him or he was hesitating to sign the contract??..........c'mon now.........


the point in bold i dispute.......if you are going to **** on the Hatton Floyd fought then what about the one Manny fought???? When people say **** like this do they realise they are ****ting on Manny's resume more than they are on Floyd's??


Same goes for ODLH. Additionally ppl like to bring up the SD to indicate it was a close fight. It wasn't.........abyone who gives ODLH more than 4 rds in that one simply does not understand how to accurately score a fight.


Who does Manny have on his resume that makes it better than Floyd's???

Manny fought Hatton at 140, manny was only 138. Manny is clearly the smaller guy while floyd was the bigger guy.

I actually felt msoely vs berto would show me who has it and if berto actually learnt and grew. When floyd chose him I was like *** mosley gonna lose because the lay off was just too long and you need a in between fight before mayweather man.

I had mayweather ebating oscar easily. i dont use the sd, but manny ebat him worse and amde him quit... manny sdidnt choose 147, remembr he only had 130 diaz fight at the time

lol..you should watch more tv..find me an all time great list that doesnt include floyd.....how can manny be there and floyd not be????mannys only the p4p king cause floyd retired

floyd brainwashed everyone that hes better than srr, so they all think ok i dont believe that, but ill have him in my top 10.