Floyd is top 100 Manny is top 3 Deal with it son ..how is this possible____________

[damned1974]

You really think that's true?

Pac would beat foreman.

tito got a good left hook and is a good fighter but he got beat by mind games by hopkins

manny is one of the best at mindgames

lol@Manny being good with mindgames-aka lies that he caught and proven to be false with....

[infamous larryx]

Just wanted to clear this up.

Has any boxing expert ever called Mayweather an ATG?

damn right..why wouldnt they??

[qwerty07]

damn right..why wouldnt they??

It's just that I've never actually heard anyone on TV say "Mayweather is an all-time great."

[infamous larryx]

130 floyd is the man. 135 castillo had a grweat 2st fight... gatti is tailor made by milliemetres.. baldo isn just not that good imo oscar semi retired....

mosely was the champ but come on, he was old and that long lay off was just very bad for him.

jmm was comeback but 147 was just too much

hatton, again at 147 he was poor. 140 he had a slightly better chance but brotez was **** anyway

**** baldo, he's better than david diaz but **** him

ok ok..at 135 david diaz is a joke

140-hatton was done floyd been ****ed him up

145??is that even a division??
and clottey-best win was against judah and he was coming off of a loss

morales beat him the first time and manny rematched him after he got shut out my raheem at 135 and made him drain himself to 130 even putting in weight penalties..come on

[infamous larryx]

It's just that I've never actually heard anyone on TV say "Mayweather is an all-time great."

lol..you should watch more tv..find me an all time great list that doesnt include floyd.....how can manny be there and floyd not be????mannys only the p4p king cause floyd retired

[check hook]

130 floyd is the man. 135 castillo had a grweat 2st fight... gatti is tailor made by milliemetres.. baldo isn just not that good imo oscar semi retired....

mosely was the champ but come on, he was old and that long lay off was just very bad for him.
jmm was comeback but 147 was just too much

hatton, again at 147 he was poor. 140 he had a slightly better chance but brotez was **** anyway

**** baldo, he's better than david diaz but **** him

revisioninst history........was anyone worried about Shane's age or long layoff when they thought Floyd would never fight him or he was hesitating to sign the contract??..........c'mon now.........


the point in bold i dispute.......if you are going to **** on the Hatton Floyd fought then what about the one Manny fought???? When people say **** like this do they realise they are ****ting on Manny's resume more than they are on Floyd's??


Same goes for ODLH. Additionally ppl like to bring up the SD to indicate it was a close fight. It wasn't.........abyone who gives ODLH more than 4 rds in that one simply does not understand how to accurately score a fight.


Who does Manny have on his resume that makes it better than Floyd's???

[Castor_Troy]

just wondering why people act like mannys resume is better than floyds..it really isnt..they arnt far apart on the atg list..manny has 7 divisional titles-never been done before

floyd remained undefeated while winning 5 divisional titles-never been done before..and in all honesty both are 7 time champs..floyd beat mosley while he was the wba champ..offical or not he beat another current champion and is now considered the linear ww champ once again

Wrong.


That isnt Linear. Marg-Mosley wasnt for the Lineal Championship because of Mosley's loss to Cotto. BIG Dispute at RING Board but the decision was it wasnt for the Lineal title.

[infamous larryx]

Wrong.


That isnt Linear. Marg-Mosley wasnt for the Lineal Championship because of Mosley's loss to Cotto. BIG Dispute at RING Board but the decision was it wasnt for the Lineal title.

ring and linear titles arnt the same

[infamous larryx]

how is mannys resume better than floyds??

[boxasmash]