Floyd is top 100 Manny is top 3 Deal with it son ..how is this possible____________

[PensionKiller]

just wondering why people act like mannys resume is better than floyds..it really isnt..they arnt far apart on the atg list..manny has 7 divisional titles-never been done before

floyd remained undefeated while winning 5 divisional titles-never been done before..and in all honesty both are 7 time champs..floyd beat mosley while he was the wba champ..offical or not he beat another current champion and is now considered the linear ww champ once again

resume wise wlad, pac and floyd got it

but wlad aint top atg

floyd is a atg but top 50, he just missing the heart to fight the best, none of this fantasy what if's. he needs to do it rather than carefully wait and see weaknesses

cotto prime

hatton barely beat collazo at 147

jmm losing many rounds to juan diaz

mosely over 1 year lay off

good names but just careful. pac done it too i guess but he had to test 145/7 waters

manny needs clean up ww to get top 2

[check hook]

Both of these guys resumes and achievements are commsensurate so i do not see how they can be so far apart on any ranking system you care to use. These two are within a few spots of each other each way.

[check hook]

resume wise wlad, pac and floyd got it

but wlad aint top atg

floyd is a atg but top 50, he just missing the heart to fight the best, none of this fantasy what if's. he needs to do it rather than carefully wait and see weaknesses

cotto prime

hatton barely beat collazo at 147

jmm losing many rounds to juan diaz

mosely over 1 year lay off

good names but just careful. pac done it too i guess but he had to test 145/7 waters

manny needs clean up ww to get top 2

who should floyd fight????

Did he not fight the best at 130 and 135. Did he not beat much better versions of ODLH and Haton than Pac did.

A SSM at 147 that just smashed Margarito > than a Cotto @ 145 who just got smashed by Margarito.......


Did anyone see weakness in Shane when he cracked Margarito like an egg?

.Think of it this way......Pac blew up to the status he enjoys now after he beat ODLH and Hatton--------> Floyd beat better versions of both and also blew up after he beat both.

[infamous larryx]

resume wise wlad, pac and floyd got it

but wlad aint top atg

floyd is a atg but top 50, he just missing the heart to fight the best, none of this fantasy what if's. he needs to do it rather than carefully wait and see weaknesses

cotto prime

hatton barely beat collazo at 147

jmm losing many rounds to juan diaz

mosely over 1 year lay off

good names but just careful. pac done it too i guess but he had to test 145/7 waters

manny needs clean up ww to get top 2

fight the best???i just proved floyd has fought the best..dont know why people say this

at 130-hernendez,manfredy,corrales-all the best at 130
at 135-castillo-one of the best lightweights ever
at 140-gatti-top 3 at 140
at 147-baldo-linear champ..judah-former linear champ,mosley-linear champ
at 154-oscar-top 5

how hasnt floyd fought the best??

his last 5 fights

mosley-wba champ-p4p#3
jmm-comeback fight-lightweight linear champ-p4p#2
hatton-undefeated 140 linear champ,former wba ww champ
oscar-wbc 154 champ
baldo-linear ww champ

[infamous larryx]

Both of these guys resumes and achievements are commsensurate so i do not see how they can be so far apart on any ranking system you care to use. These two are within a few spots of each other each way.

thats my point...............

[PensionKiller]

fight the best???i just proved floyd has fought the best..dont know why people say this

at 130-hernendez,manfredy,corrales-all the best at 130
at 135-castillo-one of the best lightweights ever
at 140-gatti-top 3 at 140
at 147-baldo-linear champ..judah-former linear champ,mosley-linear champ
at 154-oscar-top 5

how hasnt floyd fought the best??

his last 5 fights

mosley-wba champ-p4p#3
jmm-comeback fight-lightweight linear champ-p4p#2
hatton-undefeated 140 linear champ,former wba ww champ
oscar-wbc 154 champ
baldo-linear ww champ

130 floyd is the man. 135 castillo had a grweat 2st fight... gatti is tailor made by milliemetres.. baldo isn just not that good imo oscar semi retired....

mosely was the champ but come on, he was old and that long lay off was just very bad for him.

jmm was comeback but 147 was just too much

hatton, again at 147 he was poor. 140 he had a slightly better chance but brotez was **** anyway

**** baldo, he's better than david diaz but **** him

[qwerty07]

Just wanted to clear this up.

Has any boxing expert ever called Mayweather an ATG?

[check hook]

thats my point...............

i know.....and i'm, on here supporting you point because i agree with it

[BigStereotype]

posted by pensionkiller...please explain how this is possible...who do you rank manny above and why??

Look at your own damn sig. He's wrong. That's all there is to it.

[PensionKiller]

i know.....and i'm, on here supporting you point because i agree with it

i changed it to top 50

i'm out, too many haters in here