**2003 Roy Jones Jr. vs 2008 Joe Calzaghe @175**

[Killa Killa]

Roy was very drained in that fight. Why not the Roy that fought Kelly or Woods, his last two fights before going to HW?

That's the version of Roy I had in mind when I created this thread....assuming he didn't fight Ruiz in 2003...

[Killa Killa]

Joe outpoints him. Roy was real sluggish and flatfooted in that fight

Fair enough....

[Ivansmamma]

Naw......

But we can go with the Roy Jones in the first Tarver fight then...

Roy was very drained in that fight. Why not the Roy that fought Kelly or Woods, his last two fights before going to HW?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

Calzaghe destroys him again

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Naw......

But we can go with the Roy Jones in the first Tarver fight then...

Joe outpoints him. Roy was real sluggish and flatfooted in that fight

[mines a pasty]

whilst the Roy of old is an ATG, in fact my personal own favourite ATG fighter, i have to say that i see JC winning by UD or split. I hate to say that, and not for one moment do i consider JC a better boxer than Roy, because i dont, Roy was much better in his prime. I say it because that damn style of Joe's just beats Roy, no more plain and simple than that.

But ask me who is the better fighter. Period.

It's Roy all the way home.

[Killa Killa]

Thats not what happened though, is it?

Naw......

But we can go with the Roy Jones in the first Tarver fight then...

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I know, I'm saying, say he didn't fight @ 225 in 2003 and just stuck with 175 coming off the Clinton Woods win...

Thats not what happened though, is it?

[D-MiZe]

Make this fairer, Calzaghe without fucked up hands.

He'd KO Jones.

[Killa Killa]

Jones didnt fight at LHW in 2003 before Ruiz

I know, I'm saying, say he didn't fight @ 225 in 2003 and just stuck with 175 coming off the Clinton Woods win...