In my opinion Floyd is now an ATG top 20 lock

[Jermaine83]

He may be talented, but you dont rank by skill. then Roy Jones would be top 10 too. Floyd hasnt done enough, he hasnt beaten enough good opposition. if you look at the current 20 ATG they have all beaten other ATGs. Floyd hasnt, as far as i am concerned. but if he keeps on fighting for a year or two he can absolutely make the top 20.

ok,i see your point but to be honest there are not lot of fighters who can compete with floyd at welterweight although floyd is one of the smallest welters out there. i think if he beats p.will,pac,martinez all decisively then he defintely got be ranked with the all time greats. but i get your point.skill wise floyd is one of the best ever but competition is missing.i just dont think it is fair to say he could not compete or be the best or one of the best in another era because look how he dominates in this era.
In floyd toughest fight,he had a torn whatever so i gave him benefit of doubt,but apart from that he has looked tooo good.

[Pirao]

He has top 10 skills, but probably doesnt crack top 40 or 50 atg. Yes he has many accomplishments, jumping from class to class, but Floyd hasnt really beaten more than one or two opponents where you didnt think he was going to win going in.

****** criteria, so if you're so good that you're always considered the favourite you can't be great? GTFO.

[BigStereotype]

You could make a case. I'd disagree, but you could make a case. But a lock? I don't think so.