James Toney Or Lennox Lewis? Who's Greater?

[W1LL]

Lewis with ease. Don't take the piss.

[General Zod]

Lewis with ease. Don't take the piss.

Based on what? His best wins are a shot Tyson and a debatable win over a past prime Holyfield. I had him claerly winning the first fight though.

[Irish Hitman]

Lewis he had the better wins, against tyson, vitali etc

[BrooklynBomber]

Gay Jamaican to me was a greater fighter

[iron mike tyson]

Based on what? His best wins are a shot Tyson and a debatable win over a past prime Holyfield. I had him claerly winning the first fight though.

and dominating a very strong division dont stack up to lewis claim??

[krazyn8tive]

I don't even understand how anyone is arguing for toney in this one. Lennox takes it hands down

[General Zod]

Lewis he had the better wins, against tyson, vitali etc

Tyson was beyond shot, and Lewis refused to give Vitali a rematch. I f he didnt retire he was going to be stripped by the WBC

[General Zod]

and dominating a very strong division dont stack up to lewis claim??

What top fighters did Lewis beat according to you?

[krazyn8tive]

Tyson was beyond shot, and Lewis refused to give Vitali a rematch. I f he didnt retire he was going to be stripped by the WBC

The last true UNDISPUTED heavyweight and LINEAL CHAMPION...Lennox Lewis. Have a nice day

[General Zod]

I don't even understand how anyone is arguing for toney in this one. Lennox takes it hands down

Based on what Criteria? who did Lewis beat that was comparable to Nunn or McCallum? Toney koed Holyfield something that Lewis couldnt do in 24 rounds