JMM ,Hops, Cotto, Donaire and C.C.: Should NOT be on the P4P Lists.

[Glamour Puss]

You can't take JMM off that list for 1 loss.


A loss that occurred 3 divisions north of his natural weight and against a cheater who didn't bother making weight.

Bitchmade thread burner...

[Pacquiao'd]

how come people keep overrated Pwill. Martinez beat that ass and hes beat Pwill even easier the nxt time

[daggum]

Why should Marquez not be on the list, because he lost to an atg welter weight in floyd mayweather ? idiot.

when did that happen? baldomir? hatton? marquez? mitchell? oh judah ok.

[BMWM3P]

1. Manny Pacquiao

2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.

3. Shane Mosley

4. Paul Williams

5. Chad Dawson

6. Andre Dirrell

7. Andre Ward

8. Timothy Bradley

9. Hozumi Hasegawa

10. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam


It should include these 10 fighters in whatever order you see fit.

Like you have any clue of what your talking about.

And that's not a P4P list with the exeption os Pac it's just a Burner nuthugging wishlist.

[Sumakwel]

Putting Americans again as usual.

[Iceta Lives]

Devon Alexander deserves to be in there ten times more than Dirrell does. Other than that, not a bad list. I'd have Mosley over Floyd though because beating Margarito means more than beating JMM while making him move up in weight even if he was ranked #2 P4P at the time.

[Iceta Lives]

Dude you're so full of ****!!!

Only 3 non black dudes lol.

Other than Dirrell being on it, what's so bad about it? Why should Kessler be on there? Why should Abraham be on there? Why should Cotto be on there? Why should Margarito be on there? Why should Juan Ma Lopez, Gamoba, and Caballero be on there? Who do you want to be put in there? You think that's a racist list just because it doesn't have the Klitchko brothers on it? Lol. All the fighters on that list are either better fighters than the ones I mentioned above or they have better resumes. Let's see how Adamek does at Heavyweight before putting him on there even though I admit he should at least get some consideration. And Burner is spot on with JMM. He's throwing the end of his career down the drain and wasting it on a Diaz rematch.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Other than Dirrell being on it, what's so bad about it? Why should Kessler be on there? Why should Abraham be on there? Why should Cotto be on there? Why should Margarito be on there? Why should Juan Ma Lopez, Gamoba, and Caballero be on there? Who do you want to be put in there? You think that's a racist list just because it doesn't have the Klitchko brothers on it? Lol. All the fighters on that list are either better fighters than the ones I mentioned above or they have better resumes. Let's see how Adamek does at Heavyweight before putting him on there even though I admit he should at least get some consideration. And Burner is spot on with JMM. He's throwing the end of his career down the drain and wasting it on a Diaz rematch.

Yeah he thinks Im making a Pro-Black list but I asked him 3 times to make a list witjout Cotto, JMM, Donaire, and C.C.

You will have a lot of black fighters there. I wasnt being biased at all.

[TOBYLEE1]

Both fighters are coming off of loses. They put up a spectacular fight the last time they met them having a rematch makes a lot of sense.

It's not like Marquez gave Diaz a one sided beating.

I agree with that

[Iceta Lives]

And yes, JMM needs to be dropped from the list. You don't fight a rematch with a guy you already KOd and move down in weight to do it. To me, I'd keep JMM on there even if he lost to Floyd if he hadn't have done that. He's lost a lot of respect from me.