Haney did survive thanks to clinching and I think there were at least two knockdowns in round 7 that is why I approve pushing, which is generally against the rules - you hurt your opponent, he falls in a knockdown, but he tricks the rules rushing to hold onto you while falling and the referees often call it a no-knock down. On the other hand, Garcia held a lot too, plus he did a lot of holding and punching and on top of all the dirty game (his was the dirtier), he was constantly turning his back. Overall, deserved one more point deducted. And here come different interpretations:
If round 7 is 9:7 for Garcia and he gets one more point deducted for the overall dirtier game, the fight goes draw
If he gets another point deducted for a dirty game but keeps round 7 9-8, then Haney barely wins
If he doesn't get a second point deducted but gets 9-7 for round 7, then Garcia gets a close victory
It's a weird fight to score. I see why the scales are tipping towards Garcia and I would agree with a close victory, but not 114-110 or 115-109. I see it as 112-112.
Performances like these make me wonder how many losses would Haney have had today if the rules were applied to him and if there was fair judging.
I had Linares losing, but he had a chance to stop Haney. Haney’s hugging for 3 rounds led him to survive. The ref did nothing about it.
With Lomachenko, those scorecards were wrong. Lomachenko won that one widely imo.
With Ryan Garcia, again, Haney survived because the ref saved him by not following the rules of professional boxing. Not applying them on Haney.
If there was fair judging and officiating, Haney could absolutely be 28-3 right now. Lots of leeway and second chances. And now I wonder if it is true that he also had a professional defeat in Mexico that was wiped off his record with a payment.
Comment