My new P4P rankings (OF ALL TIME)

[Mersey]

This is the worst list I've seen. It's got to be fake or a joke.

[PAC-MANIA]

This is the worst list I've seen. It's got to be fake or a joke.

please state your arguement...tell me why those fighters dont deserve to be on there ???

[Mersey]

#1. Sugar Ray Robinson
#2. Muhammad Ali
#3. Roy Jones Jr.
#4. Joe Louis
#5. Archie Moore
#6. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
#7. Manny Pacquiao
#8. Mike Tyson
#9. Roberto Duran
#10. Rocky Marciano


Those are my honest calculations

1. Sugar Ray Robinson - Deserves this spot
#2. Muhammad Ali -Deserves this spot
#3. Roy Jones Jr. - Was a great fighter but no even top 10 IMO
#4. Joe Louis - Deserves this spot
#5. Archie Moore
#6. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Very skilled, but hasn't done anywhere near enough to be number 6 or anywhere near number 6.
#7. Manny Pacquiao - Same as Mayweather
#8. Mike Tyson - Mike Tyson isn't even a top 8 heavyweight so why number 8 on p4p?
#9. Roberto Duran - Deserves this spot
#10. Rocky Marciano - Maybe top 30

[PAC-MANIA]

1. Sugar Ray Robinson - Deserves this spot
#2. Muhammad Ali -Deserves this spot
#3. Roy Jones Jr. - Was a great fighter but no even top 10 IMO
#4. Joe Louis - Deserves this spot
#5. Archie Moore
#6. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Very skilled, but hasn't done anywhere near enough to be number 6 or anywhere near number 6.
#7. Manny Pacquiao - Same as Mayweather
#8. Mike Tyson - Mike Tyson isn't even a top 8 heavyweight so why number 8 on p4p?
#9. Roberto Duran - Deserves this spot
#10. Rocky Marciano - Maybe top 30

yea marciano was only an undefeated heavyweight who faced all the top fighters

[jrosales13]

1. Sugar Ray Robinson - Deserves this spot
#2. Muhammad Ali -Deserves this spot
#3. Roy Jones Jr. - Was a great fighter but no even top 10 IMO
#4. Joe Louis - Deserves this spot
#5. Archie Moore
#6. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Very skilled, but hasn't done anywhere near enough to be number 6 or anywhere near number 6.
#7. Manny Pacquiao - Same as Mayweather
#8. Mike Tyson - Mike Tyson isn't even a top 8 heavyweight so why number 8 on p4p?
#9. Roberto Duran - Deserves this spot
#10. Rocky Marciano - Maybe top 30

Do you have top 10? If you can make a top 25 you should. I think is very hard to do so. I think Chavez is a lil too high on my list I am not sure I might change it.

[Mersey]

yea marciano was only an undefeated heavyweight who faced all the top fighters

The HW's he faced at the time weren't all that great. Being undefeated doesn't get you a top 10 p4p spot.

[jrosales13]

yea marciano was only an undefeated heavyweight who faced all the top fighters

Marciano faced all the top fighters like Floyd Patterson and fighters of that ilk right?

[PAC-MANIA]

The HW's he faced at the time weren't all that great. Being undefeated doesn't get you a top 10 p4p spot.

LMFAO it wasnt tysons fault he made everyone look like tomato cans.......pure skill wise he was top 5 EVER ... in history. his head movement...his foot work....his speed and power...my god it was awesome. same with marciano. the only reason you **** on marciano is cuz u never watched him fight. watch 10 or 15 of his fights and graduate from elementary school then you can tlk to me about boxing

[Mersey]

Do you have top 10? If you can make a top 25 you should. I think is very hard to do so. I think Chavez is a lil too high on my list I am not sure I might change it.

Nah I don't have a top 25 list. It'd would take too much time and effort for me to make one. And I'd probably change my mind every day

[jrosales13]

Nah I don't have a top 25 list. It'd would take too much time and effort for me to make one. And I'd probably change my mind every day

lol I know what you mean. I did my top 25 and I have changed my mine like 10 times already. Do you have a top 10?