Originally posted by hugh grant View Post
No he didn’t. They didn’t fight the same guys. Fishnets was drained against Manny. Cotto was at a cw. Floyd beat undefeated Hatton. Manny beat the one coming down in weight, post ko.
( Note- as much as you and others talk about how the ko affected Manny when he fought Floyd, it’s fair to say the Floyd ko affected Hatton. So this win by Manny is reduced, right??)
Floyd beat Shane before Manny. Floyd beat JMM decisively. Manny never beat JMM that way.
Bottom line is Manny doesn’t have any wins over someone as good as Floyd or who Floyd beat. He also lost to Floyd. You can’t credibly argue he’s better.
Duran beat SRL. He beat Hagler and is also ranked ahead of him On almost every credible list of ATGS.
That is why your post doesn’t apply to Manny.
Comment